What is a lease under the LPA 1925?
A proprietary right called a ‘term of years absolute’ under s.1(1)(b) and defined in s.205(1)(xxvii).
How is a lease different from a licence?
A lease grants a proprietary right and is enforceable against third parties; a licence is a personal right enforceable only against the licensor.
Why is the distinction between a lease and a licence important?
It affects enforceability, statutory protections, and remedies.
What case established the importance of substance over form in lease/licence distinction?
Street v Mountford [1985] AC 809.
What are the three key elements of a lease?
Certainty of term, exclusive possession, and correct formalities.
Can the payment of rent be a determining factor?
No, rent is not essential (Ashburn Anstalt v Arnold [1989]).
What does exclusive possession mean?
The right to exclude all others, including the landlord.
What does ‘certainty of term’ mean in lease law?
The lease must be granted for a term that is certain from the outset.
What are the two forms of certain term?
Fixed term and periodic term.
What is a fixed term lease?
A lease with a maximum duration known from the outset.
What is a periodic tenancy?
A tenancy that continues from period to period until notice is given.
How is a periodic tenancy created?
Expressly in writing or implied by conduct, such as regular rent payments.
What determines the period of a periodic tenancy?
The period by reference to which rent is calculated.
What case illustrates failure to meet certainty of term?
Lace v Chantler [1944] - lease ‘for duration of war’ was invalid.
What case dealt with implied periodic tenancy?
Prudential Assurance v London Residuary Body [1992].
What is required to prove exclusive possession?
The occupier must be able to exclude others, including the landlord.
Does a landlord retaining a key defeat exclusive possession?
No, unless the right of access is unrestricted or actively used.
What is a sham clause?
A clause inserted to disguise a lease as a licence, which courts may disregard.
What was held in Aslan v Murphy [1990]?
Retention of a key doesn’t prevent exclusive possession if not regularly used.
What is the significance of Marchant v Charters [1977]?
Provision of services indicates a licence, not a lease.
What happens when landlords introduce others to share?
This may negate exclusive possession if the clause is genuine.
What was decided in AG Securities v Vaughan?
No joint tenancy due to lack of unity in agreement details.
What was decided in Antoniades v Villiers?
A couple had a joint tenancy despite separate agreements.
Can multiple occupiers have a lease?
Yes, if they hold a joint tenancy.