Formalities for a legal mortgage
Deed, which only has to be signed by the grantor/borrower + Registration
mortgagee
lender
mortgagor
borrower
Who needs to sign a mortgage deed?
grantor/borrower only, not the lender
priority of repayment for mortgages
all mortgages must be repaid in the order in which they are registered
If a mortgage intended to be legal is not created properly, what is the consequence?
The mortgage will be equitable provided that it is in writing, contains all the terms and is signed by both parties.
Equitable mortgage
applies where the borrower only holds an equitable interest in the land or has a defective legal mortgage
Formalities for equitable mortgage
in writing + signed by the grantor (the borrower)
defective legal mortgage
Equity will recognise “a contract to grant a legal mortgage” if in writing, contains all agreed terms and signed by mortgagor/mortgagee
Requirements for a deed
intended to be a deed, validly executed + delivered
When does the borrower’s equitable right to redeem arise?
On the day after the legal date for redemption has passed
irrebuttable presumption of ascendancy
parent/child, solicitor/client, trustee/beneficiary, guardian/ward
relationships where undue influence must be positively shown
parent/adult child; husband/wife
2 types of undue influence
(1) overt acts of improper pressure
(2) ascendancy over another, which is taken advantage of
Why are options to purchase in a mortgage agreement likely to be struck down?
can be struck down as a “clog” on equity of redemption - the court will look at “substance” rather than “label” to decide whether it is substantially a mortgage
solus tie
a collateral advantage in a commercial transaction eg obligation to source supplies from the lender. usually upheld.
Elements required to successfully prove undue influence
A relationship of trust and confidence
A transaction which requires explanation
Burden of proof for undue influence
on the alleged victim/claimant
Remedies for undue influence
the contract may be set aside (on a discretionary and equitable basis)
When are banks/lenders put on inquiry of undue influence?
whenever one party in a non-commercial setting is standing as surety for the other party
When is a lender NOT put on notice of undue influence?
if the purpose of the loan is for the joint benefit of the co-owners
Etridge guidelines
Where the bank is put on notice of undue influence, they must:
(1) Write to the spouse who is granting the mortgage not for their benefit, explaining that it needs confirmation from an independent solicitor that they have explained the transaction to the spouse;
(2) Ask that party to nominate an independent solicitor, provide all information to that independent solicitor; and
(3) Must not proceed to lend until confirmation is received from the independent solicitor that the transaction has been fully explained
Priority of legal mortgages depends on
order of registration
Priority of equitable mortgages depends on
order of creation