Property Practice Flashcards

(310 cards)

1
Q

is exchange of contracts a compulsory stage in a property transaction?

A

no, but very useful

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

at what stage do the parties become bound to the freehold property transaction?

A

exchange of contracts

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

what impact does the ‘caveat emptor’ principle have on the stages of a freehold property transaction?

A
  • buyer beware
  • buyers are expected to conduct their own due diligence, including physical inspections, legal investigations, and reviewing any information provided by the seller.
  • While sellers are obligated to answer pre-contract inquiries truthfully, they are not generally required to volunteer information about hidden defects.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

what should the seller’s sol provide to the buyer in the pre-contract stage?

A
  • pre-contract package of documents
  • e.g. a draft contract and evidence of the seller’s title
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

why is it important for the buyer’s sol to check the title docs at the pre-contract stage?

A

contracts will usually include a provision prohibiting the buyer from raising further queries on the title, known as ‘requisitions’, after exchange

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

what happens in the pre-completion stage?

A
  • making sure all the correct docs (including transfer deed) and the completion monies will be available on completion
  • running necessary checks again to ensure no changes from pre-contracts stage
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

what happens in the post-completion stage?

A
  • admin matters
  • discharge of mortgage
  • SLDT
  • buyer’s sol = register buyer as new owner and register any mortgage
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

do the following present a conflict of interest in the purchase of property or do one of the exceptions apply?

  • ‘substantially common interest’
  • ‘competing for the same objective’
  • acting for joint buyers
  • acting for a borrower and lender in residential property
  • lender and borrower in large commercial property transactions
A
  • ‘substantially common interest’ exception = doesn’t apply to property purchase
  • (buyer and seller = different interests)
  • ‘competing for the same objective’ = could act for two buyers in purchasing the same property, but not buyer and seller
  • joint buyers = usually acceptable where both have given informed consent, safeguards are put in place to protect clients confidentiality and it is reasonable for you to act
  • borrower and lender = acting for both is possible unless there is a conflict or significant risk of one and an exception doesn’t apply i.e where it is not a standard mortgage or the mortgage is a standard mortgage but you do not use the approved certificate of title

large com prop transactions = usually have separate sols as there is likely to be negotiations as to price + it wont be on standard terms

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

what is a solicitor’s duty regarding contract races?

A
  • contract races = legitimate selling technique
  • buyers must be made aware they are engaged in a race
  • the solicitor should inform all buyers immediately of the seller’s intention to deal with more than one buyer
  • if the seller refuses to agree to such disclosure > cease acting
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

acting for joint borrowers usually doesnt present a conflict of interest - what is the exception to this?

A

matrimonial home co-owned and one decides to use it as security for business loan > Etridge (undue influence)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

what is the right of apportionment?

A

regarding sale of residential property

where you apportion some of the purchase price to valuable chattels you may want to keep when you buy a house e.g. curtains, free standing fridge etc

you dont have to pay SDLT on

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

how is SDLT paid?

what are the consequences of not paying it?

A
  • paid to HMRC
  • SDLT1
  • must be paid within 14 days of completion
  • if it is not paid, the transfer of the property to the buyer will not be registered by the LR
  • also attracts penalties and interest
  • send SDLT 5 to HMRC to prove payment
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

how is LTT paid?

A
  • land transaction return for LTT must be submitted to the Welsh Revenue Authority within 30 days of completion
  • WRA certificate
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

what are the tax implications of a residential property which is for sale, having a garden grater than 0.5 hectares?

A

charged capital gains tax on the excess land unless you can show to HMRC that land is necessary for the reasonable enjoyment of the home.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

can you claim private residence relief if you have more than one residential homes?

A

yes - you can elect to HMRC which residence obtains this relief

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

how can private residence relief assist trustees?

A

trustees where the property is occupied by a beneficiary as their principal residence

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

what are the two main types of mortgages?

A

repayment mortgages (repayment of some of the lump sum + interest)

interest only mortgages

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

who would be considered a VAT sensitive buyer and why might they be put off purchasing old commercial property where the seller chooses to add VAT?

A
  • banks building societies and insurance providers
  • they only provide non-vatable services

so if they try to buy a property in which the seller chooses to add the VAT, they will be paying 20% extra on the price, which they then wont be able to recover through their own services.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

why might a non-VAT-sensitive buyer purchase an old commercial property where the seller chooses to add VAT?

A

if they pay the VAT, they are paying 20% more but they can offset this through charging VAT for their own goods and services - makes no difference to them in real terms

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

why might a seller choose to add VAT to the sale of an old commercial property?

A

if they have spent money on the property which they have been charged VAT on, e.g. they have brought builders in to renovate, they can only recover this if they end up charging VAT on the sale of the property.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

if a seller decides to add VAT to the purchase price of an old commercial property, what must they do?

A

inform HMRC

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

a seller of an old commercial property is a bank, are they able to opt to charge VAT on the sale of the property?

A

If you only sell or supply exempt goods and services, then your business is exempt, you cannot register for VAT and you cannot recover any input tax

building societies and insurance companies also apply to this

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

what is deemed as old commercial property for the purposes of VAT on sale?

A

if the property was completed more than 3 years prior to the point of sale = old

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

Planning permission is required for an activity that constitutes ‘development’ - Town and Country Planning Act

define ‘ development ‘ and where in legislation is it found (need to know this)

A

‘Development’ = the carrying out of building, engineering, mining or other operations in, on, over or under land, or the making of any material change in the use of any buildings or other land.

  • s 55 TCPA 1990

BEMOM acronym

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
what is excluded from the definition of development and therefore doesn't require planning permission?
1. any works which only affect the interior of the building + do not materially affect the external appearance - don't require PP 2. changes of use to another use, or mix of uses, within the same use class will not require planning permission
26
Changes to and from a ________ use will always require planning permission. what falls under this class?
sui generis - one of a kind - could have adverse affect the locality i) entertainment establishments e.g. cinemas/bingo halls ii) drinking establishments e.g. pubs and wine bars iii) hot food takeaways (for consumption off the premises)
27
as a general rule, once implemented, planning permission usually ___________________________ and any conditions attached to it will ____________________________
runs with the land forever burden the land forever
28
do planning permissions impose a time in which the development needs to be completed?
NOT USUALLY but IF LPA DECIDES that completion will not take place within a reasonable time, it can serve a COMPLETION NOTICE stating that the permission will cease to have effect if completion has not taken place by the expiration period stated in the notice completion notices = rare
29
does planning permission give the developer the permission to use the land in some way and ignore any covenants affecting the land?
no - the grant of planning permission is effective for planning purposes only may still need approval to use the land in some way and there still may be covenants on the land which cannot be breached
30
it is not always necessary to apply expressly for planning permission as, in some cases, it is automatically granted - where are these rights located in legislation? (technically you still need planning permission just not the express form of PP you would usually obtain)
Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 2015 (‘GDPO 2015’) + Welsh version = same but 1995 GDPO
31
It is possible for the Secretary of State in charge of Town and Country Planning, or the LPA, to exclude the effect of the relevant GPDO providing for automatic planning permission rights, how would they do this?
by issuing an Article 4 Direction a sol should check the latest version of the GPDO to see if there have been any article 4 directions made
32
if there is doubt regarding whether a development would fall under a GPDO, what should be done?
apply for a Certificate of Lawfulness of Proposed Use or Development under s 192 of the TCPO 1990
33
regarding automatic planning rights, if they do not fall under a _______ and a _______ has not be obtained, a developer should apply for express planning permission
General Permitted Development Order Certificate of Lawfulness of Proposed Use or Development
34
if the LPA THINKS someone has developed property in contravention of planning control, what powers does the LPA have to get more info?
can exercise a RIGHT OF ENTRY to the property or serve a PLANNING CONTRAVENTION NOTICE, which requires the recipient to provide INFORMATION about operations, use, or activities being carried out on the land and any matter relating to the conditions attached to a planning permission
35
what enforcement options does the LPA have if someone is developing in contravention of planning control?
1. enforcement notice 2. stop notice 3. breach of condition notice 4. injunction
36
what is an enforcement notice, what does it need to contain?
- informs of breach of planning control - must be served on the owner, occupier and any other person having an interest in the land, such as a mortgagee - becomes effective 28 days after service - the notice must: i) allege the breach ii) steps to be taken to remedy iii) timescale for remedy - a person with an interest in the land can appeal the enforcement notice - enforcement warning notice > invitation to the recipient to regularise the breach by applying for a retrospective planning permissioN
37
what is a stop notice, how does it work? how is a temporary stop notice different?
because the enforcement notice cannot take effect until 28 days after recipient has received it, and can be suspended if appealed, a stop notice works in the interim to stop all activities in relation to the land - cannot be served by itself, enforcement notice must be served first - but can serve temporary stop notice (even if enforcement notice hasnt been served) to allow for investigation - 56 days only
38
how can a LPA use an injunction? (think of acronym ENA) how long could the injunction last for?
- ACTUAL OR APPREHENDED BREACH - discretionary so LPA will need to show it is EXPEDIENT, NECCESSARY AND APPROPRIATE remedy - discretionary - time limit = 10 years
38
what is a breach of condition notice?
v similar to an enforcement notice but can only be served a condition of planning is not being met no right of appeal
39
how is the time limit for enforcement by an LPA changed if the breach of the planning control has been concealed?
- action can be taken after - apply to mags - planning enforcement order
40
what is failure to comply with planning control notices punishable by?
fine
41
who is held responsible for any breach in planning control?
the owner of the land - not necessarily the person who tried to obtain the PP which is why it is so important for buyers sols to check the planning history of the land at the pre-contract stage
42
what are building control regulations? are they intrinsically linked with planning permission?
regulations related to the heath and safety of construction or alteration both building control regulations and PP are usually considered together but it may be necessary to get building control consent even where the works themselves do not require planning permission
43
what happens after you have made an application to the building control authority for building control consent?
- the work is inspected by a building control officer - inspection (s) - after final inspection - certificate of compliance issued by BCA
44
what is the impact of self- certification schemes regulated by trades and professions (eg plumbing and installation of windows)?
- dont need to make separate application to the building control authority regarding building control consent - self-certify the work - relevant body sends notification to the building control authority
45
building control authorities can now prosecute for breaches of building control regs, in what time frame must the prosecution be brought?
england = no time limit
46
BCA can also issue enforcement notices, what is the timeframe in which they must issue these? what other enforcement options does a BCA have for a potential breach of the building control regs?
england = within 10 years other option = injunctions if the work is unsafe - no time limit
47
which parties would be concerned if a property had not obtained building control consent? can any action be taken by these parties to ensure the building is brough up to standard?
buyer and lender if consent has not been given - ask the seller to obtain a regularisation certificate from the BCA detailing what works would be required to bring the property up to standard or get insurance - but wont cover personal injury or business interruption for a defective building
48
what are listed buildings, and what do they include?
- architectural or historic interest - decided by gov. - building and any object or structure fixed to the building or within the curtilage of the building that forms part of the land and has done so since before 1 July 1948.
49
what is the impact of a building being listed?
- PP + listed building consent = external alterations
50
LPAs are under obligations to designate to conserve areas in what circumstances?
any parts of their own area that are of SPECIAL ARCHITECTURAL OR HISTORIC INTEREST, the CHARACTER AND APPEARANCE of which it is DESIRABLE TO PRESERVE OR ENHANCE.
51
what is the impact of an area being designated a conservation area?
- more liekly to need PP - tree conservation area works - notify 6 weeks before
52
how does investigation of title effect a lender?
because if the borrower defaults on the mortgage, the lender wants to know they can sell the property for at least the value of the outstanding loan - if there has been an unsatisfactory investigation of title and there are some burdens on the land the lender wasnt originally told about, this will affect the market value of the property and thus the amount they can recoup
53
when a seller's sols produces a first draft of a sale contract, it should include what promise?
the seller promises to sell the property ‘free from incumbrances’ unless it otherwise states this is why it is also important for a seller's sols to investigate the title - they need to be aware of any encumbrances on the land before drafting the first draft of the sale contract
54
which two documents should the seller's sol obtain when investigating the title of the seller's land?
from the Land Reg : title - ' official copies ' title plan
55
what is meant by deduction of title? when is this completed? who pays for this? how old should the documents be? is there anything else the buyer's sol would need to investigate at this stage?
- seller's obligation to prove their ownership of the property to the buyer - should be done before exchange of contracts - buyer usually prevented from raising objections to the title after the exchange of contracts - SELLER'S OWN EXPENSE to provide buyer with title and plan copies NO MORE THAN 6 MONTHS OLD - the buyer's sol will also need to investigate if there are any overriding interests
56
what is the difference between the 'edition date' and the 'search from date' on official copies of the register of title
edition date - when the LR last updated the title
57
the official copies of the registered title can be found in three places, what are they and how are they different?
(a) the Property register - description of the land by postcode - freehold / leasehold - easements - if anything you would usually expect to come with the land has been excluded (e.g. right to light) (b) the Proprietorship register - identifies current owners and their address - class of title (3 classes - determined when first register freehold title) - the state guarantees the title and offers compensation if there are defects with it - may indicate price paid for the property by the current owners (but only if the land has been sold since 1 April 2000) - will show if the owners gave an indemnity covenant when purchased the land - will show chain of indemnity covenants - restrictions on the owners ability to sell (since 13 October 2003, the LR has provided only two types of entry for the protection of third party interests – notices and restrictions) (c) the Charges register - identifies any incumbrances - a sol will be looking out for: (i) covenant (ii) easements (iii) charges over the land, most commonly mortgages (iv) leases granted over the whole or part of the property (v) notices registered by third parties claiming an interest in the property - some of the above will be a problem for the buyer, others won't
58
what are the three classes of title for registered freehold land? what impact do the classes have on a buyer? Think APQ
(i) Absolute title: the most common and best class, the registered proprietor has vested in them the legal estate SUBJECT ONLY TO THE ENTRIES ON THE REGISTER, OVERRIDING INTERESTS and where the proprietor is a trustee, minor interests of which they have notice, such as the interests of the beneficiaries under the trust. (ii) Possessory title: granted where the proprietor is in possession of the property but has LOST TITLE DEEDS OR CLAIMING THROUGH ADVERSE POSSESSION, this means that the proprietor is also subject to all adverse interests existing at the date of first registration. (iii) Qualified title: granted where there is a specific identified defect which the Registrar feels cannot be overlooked or ‘cured’ by the grant of absolute title. - can upgrade from qualified to possessory - buyer concerned if not absolute title as may affect their ability to get a loan to purchase the property + may affect their ability to sell it in the future
59
how would you go about investigating title to freehold unregistered land?
1. check if there is a pending application for first registration 2. a third party may have lodged a caution against first registration (checks can be done by an Index Map search at the Land Registry, on Form SIM (Search of the Index Map) accompanied by a plan of the property 3. if no application for first registration then title is proved by deeds (copies provided to buyer's sols before exchange - originals exchanged on completion) 4. inspection of paper deeds 5. the seller’s solicitor must consider whether any transaction in the property’s history should have triggered first registration of title - if the title should've already been registered, the seller will be required to register it before any other transactions 6. find the doc = 'root of title' - begin title investigation from here (usually most recent doc that satisfies good root of title requirements) 7. where root of title found - older docs can be disregarded unless they refer to a third party right in an earlier conveyance 8. seller's sol then creates epitome of title (schedule of all the documents from and including the root up until the present day) can proceed
60
a third party may lodge a caution against first registration - what is meant by this?
warning any person attempting to deal with the land that they have an interest in the land, such as an easement when the application for first registration is lodged, the LR will ‘warn off’ the cautioner, ie give them a limited period to establish their rights over the land and if they cannot do so, the registration will proceed and the cautioner will lose their rights
61
how does the process of checking the title of unregistered freehold land change if there is a partial sale of the land? what is the process called?
1. still check if there is an application for first registration 2. check if a third party has lodged a caution 3. if none of the above, title is proven by deeds: - rather than copies and then exchange of originals, if it is a partial sale: i) the seller keeps the originals and hands over certified copies on completion ii) completion = the buyer’s solicitor examines the original title deeds against the copies that they received prior to exchange of contracts to check they are the same; this process is referred to as ‘verification of title’ - a memorandum of the sale of part is marked on the original deed.
62
what are the requirements of a good root of title?
* deal with or show who owns the ENTIRE INTEREST (legal and equitable) that is being sold by the current owner * contain a RECOGNISABLE of the relevant land * do nothing to CAST DOUBT on the seller’s title * be at least 15 YEARS OLD (creates 'double guarantee')
63
once the root title has been discovered, all subsequent title deeds must be checked in a systematic manner, what will a sol look for?
* the chain of ownership (should be unbroken chain from root title to current seller - if owner has died, property will best in their PRs and a grant of probate identifying the PRs must also be produced) * description of the land * stamp duties * incumbrances (easements and covenants) * execution (most need to be executed as a deed s 52 LPA and for a deed to be valid - s1 LP(MP)A) * land charges searches (restrictive covenants will only bind unregistered land if they are registered at the central Land Charges Department in Plymouth) note - in investigating unregistered title, a solicitor must ensure that valid searches have been made against the names of all the estate owners revealed in the epitome of title and the attached documents, even if their period of ownership pre- dates the root of title - K15 form
64
when two people co-own a property the legal interest can only be shared via joint tenancy. the equitable interest can be shared either in joint tenancy or tenancy in common. what are the assumptions about how the equitable interest is held registered and unregistered land what should a sol do where co-owned property, is only being sold by one owner?
where property is co-owned equitable interest presumed to be held: registered land = as joint tenants unless there is a restriction on the proprietorship register unregistered land = the conveyance will state whether the equitable interest is held as JTs or TICs ______________________________________________ if title investigation shows the property is jointly owned - must find out what happened to the other co-owner - may have died (need death certificate) + if alive = must be party to the contract where there is only one surviving legal owner and the equitable interest was held by the coowners as tenants in common, another legal owner (often referred to as a ‘second trustee’) needs to be appointed to overreach the equitable interest of the deceased co- owner (by deed of appointment) otherwise the equitable interest may have passed with the will / rules of intestacy = no need to appoint second trustee here
65
a post 1925 restrictive covenant will only be binding against a buyer if what? how can this be checked?
validly registered as a D(ii) Land Charge against the name of the original covenantor checked on the Charges register
66
which will bind the buyer? restrictive covenant positive covenant
rc = binds the buyer, as runs with the land pc = need to ask whether the burden binds the seller because the burden doesn't automatically run with the land if the seller is the original covenantor or if the seller gave an an indemnity covenant to their seller when they purchased the property, thus creating or continuing a chain of indemnity - this can be checked on the proprietorship register
67
what is a chain of indemnity covenants?
This is where each successive buyer gives an indemnity to the previous owner to bear the cost of complying with the covenant. This contractual mechanism is a simple means of passing the burden of positive covenants to successors in title
68
why would a buyer not usually be concerned if there is a mortgage over the property they are buying? what duties does the buyer's sol have regarding this?
because usually the seller will use the proceeds of sale to discharge the mortgage The buyer’s solicitor should check that the contract states that the seller is selling the property free of the mortgage and that the seller’s solicitor gives an undertaking to discharge the mortgage immediately on completion
69
what impact does a notice being on the charges register of registered land have?
- acts as a warning that a third partycould have an interest in the property - does not guarantee that the interest it is valid or that it even exists - merely serves to ensure that the priority of the interest referred to in the notice is protected against any subsequent interests. - can usually just ask the seller to get the notice removed off the charges register but if the notice is for a valid interest e.g. contract for a lease to a third party = more concern
70
what options does a buyer's solicitor have when there is an unwanted restrictive covenant on the land?
1. ask the seller if they know who has the benefit of the covenant and try to come to an agreement to get it released 2. obtain a restrictive covenant insurance policy for the proposed breach of covenant - not appropriate where person with the benefit of the covenant knows they have it and are likely to object to an alternative use of the land 3. apply to the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) for modification or discharge of the covenant under s 84 Law of Property Act 1925 - argue the covenant is obsolete and the loss of it can be compensated in money some of the above may be mutually exclusive - generally not able to obtain insurance where you have also approached the person to alert them to their right If the covenant is old, the successor in title to the property with the benefit may not be aware of it, so an approach to them may not be in the client’s best interests
71
summarise the approach to investigating title for both registered and unregistered land
registered land - seller supplies official copies and title plan + searches/enquiries re any charges which may not be on the registers unregistered land - epitome of title which begins with a good root of title + Index Map search and central land charges searches
72
list the conveyancing searches that are relevant to every property
6 in total a) survey and personal inspection (by buyer's sol): - valuation (lender will always require - borrower will have to pay) - structural survey (only if required e.g. concerns or wants to carry out alterations) - 'homebuyers valuation and survey' (less detailed than structural survey but still contains advice on necessary repairs and maintenance) b) local land charges search + optional searches - form LLC1 - financial charges or restrictions iimposed by public authorities via statute - e.g. planning consents, TPOs, conservation area designation orders - standard enquiry form = CON29 - optional enquiries = CON29O c) water and drainage search - made to water company (not local authority) - CON29DW (residential properties) - CommercialDW (commercial properties) - if the property does drain into the public sewer = buyer will be liable for the costs of maintaining the drains and sewers and may be liable for the costs of bringing them up to adoption standard if the water authority decides to adopt them d) pre-contract enquiries of the seller - any disputes relating to the property - any third parties occupying the property - compliance with any covenants in the title - boundary maintenance - (for comm prop) the VAT status of the transaction e) environmental searches - costs of clean ups can be with the owner of the land (not the polluter) - desktop searches = carried out by environmental search company - specialist environmental surveyor if necessary f) flood search - where the property is close to a river or the coast - Government- backed reinsurance scheme known as ‘Flood Re’ (n/a for comm prop)
73
list the searches and enquiries for particular properties and transactions
1. chancel repairs search - no liability will exist where the property is registered and the previous transfer for value occurred after 13 October 2013 - insurance 2. mining searches (affected areas = Devon, Cornwall, Somerset, West Midlands, Cheshire) 3. canal and river trust search - liability for repairs to the maintenance of the waterways, banks and tow paths - also risk of flooding 4. commons search - properties on green- field sites or adjoining an open space such as a village green - optional enquiry 22 in the CON29O form in the local search 5. Railways - any obligations to maintain the boundary features separating the property from the railway line - whether there are any restrictions on carrying out building work next to the line - Network Rail wont answer these enquiries - the reply to enquiry 22 in the CON29 form in the local search will reveal if the property might be affected by a proposed rail scheme 6. Highways - enquiry 2 in CON29 form = some info - if not a public highway = no automatic right to use it and may also not be maintained at public's expense - developments = can send plan to highways authority asking the boundaries of the publicly maintainable highways to be marked on 7. Unregistered Land - An Index Map Search (‘SIM’) and a Land Charges Department search against the seller and previous estate owners 8. Company search - if seller = company - confirms identity of current officers (check you're dealing with the correct people) - any fixed or floating charges secured on the property that will need to be discharged on completion - check needs to be redone just before completion to check for insolvency issues - unregistered land = company searches should also be carried out against any corporate estate owners revealed in the epitome of title
74
what additional check should a solicitor who is acting for a lender as well as the buyer do before purchasing a property?
- bankruptcy/ insolvency search against the buyer / borrower - where the buyer / borrower is an individual = K16 form to the Land Charges department in Plymouth - company = company search
75
what is a tree preservation order and which conveyancing searches would show a tree preservation order?
- will present as a local land charge in the LLC1 result - criminal offence to lop or fell a tree subject to a TPO without the consent of LPA - pre- contract enquiries = buyer's sols to obtain a copy of the TPO from the seller, establish the location of the protected tree(s) and check the TPO has been complied with
76
what is a smoke control order and which conveyancing searches would show a smoke control order?
- regulation that limits the types of fuel that can be burned in certain areas of the UK to improve air quality - will show as local land charge in the LLC1 result - may be a problem where buyer has open fireplace which they intend to use
77
in which conveyancing searches would it show if a property was within a conservation area?
LLC1or CON29
78
what are the two kinds of standard conditions of sale and what are each used for?
1. Standard Conditions of Sale: - all residential transactions + some simple commercial transactions 2. The Standard Commercial Property Conditions - high value commercial properties
79
what should be check on the front page of sale contract
- particulars of sale - financial terms of the transaction: 1. who the buyer is 2. fixtures/chattels 3. price + the deposit 4. information about the seller that should be cross-referenced to: - registered land > proprietorship register - unregistered land > title deeds - registered property = need title number + class of title - unregistered property = need to reference to the root of title + specified incumbrances - if these are specified > could be in breach of SC 3.1.1
80
With both full and limited title guarantee, the seller will be impliedly covenanting in the transfer of the property 4 things. What are they?
1. They have the right to dispose of the land 2. They will do all they reasonably can to transfer the title 3. In the case of leasehold land, the lease is subsisting at the time of disposal and there is no breach of covenant making the lease liable to forfeiture. AND WITH FULL TITLE GUARANTEE... - seller is impliedly covenanting that the land is disposed of free from incumbrances other than those the seller does not know about and could not reasonably know about - s. 6 LP(MP)A limits this covenant to exclude anything the buyer new about or was entered on the registers - but this still remains a wider covenant than that provided under limited title LIMITED TITLE GUARANTEE... - the seller has not incumbered the property and is not aware anyone else has done so since the last disposition for value (so a seller is only covenanting that incumbrances have not been created since they purchased the property)
81
a contract of sale will stipulate a contract rate - what is this? do the standard conditions already provide for this?
- rate of interest that will be charged if a party is late in completing - must be high enough to incentivise a potentially defaulting party - Law Society's interest rate from time to time - the SCs and SCPCs already provide for the above rate - so if the parties are happy to use this rate, it is not necessary to fill in the gap on the front page of the contract, but it is common practice to do so - if not filled in = compensation will be calculated at The Law Society’s interest rate from time to time in force - can be otherwise negotiated - 2-4% being the normal range remember this is on top of the Barclays Base rate, so if the base rate if 5% you add the 4% (or otherwise agreed rate) so the contract rate will be 9%
82
what do the SCs and SCPCs provide for regarding deposits on the purchase of property?
- both = if the buyer fails to complete the seller may forfeit and keep the deposit - both = deposit of 10% of the purchase price is payable on exchange of contracts and is paid to the seller’s solicitor as ‘stakeholder’ - (this means that the seller’s solicitor cannot hand it over to the seller until completion) - can vary amount + to agent (via special conditions) - agent = the deposit is released to the seller immediately after exchange of contract (risk if doesnt complete = not returned + risk of insolvency) SCs - allows the seller to use the deposit as a deposit on a related purchase of a house for the seller - payment = electronic means OR cheque drawn from the conveyancer's client account SCPCs - electronic means of payment only (in both cases the funds must come from the conveyancer's bank account)
83
special conditions are found on the back page of the sale contract. what kind of things would you need a special condition for?
- exclusion of fixtures from the sale - property subject to vacant possession or subject to lease/tenancy - altering date for completion - parties should not rely on any representations that have not been made in writing - if there is a non-owning occupier > they vacate on completion - appointment of second trustee for the purposes of transfer - restrictive covenant insurance - disclosing a defect in title - a seller selling with limited or no title guarantee - inclusion of indemnity covenants (although this is usually covered in the standard conditions)
84
under both sets of standard conditions, who is liable for damage caused to the property before and after exchange of contracts?
- after exchange of contracts = buyer liable - means that the buyer must complete the purchase even if the property is damaged or destroyed between exchange and completion - where the buyer is financing the purchase with a mortgage the lender may insure the property on being requested to do by the buyer’s solicitor, but if not, the buyer will have to take out a new insurance policy - buyers with several properties may already have a ‘block policy’ to which the new property can be added - both standard conditions = the seller is under no obligation to insure a freehold property unless required to do so by a special condition in the contract
85
under both standard conditions, the seller of a property is under no obligation to insure a property in the period between exchange of contracts and completion - the buyer usually insures this period in what circumstances might a seller maintain an insurance policy?
- where the parties agree the risk should remain with the seller, eg on a new build property in the course of construction - if this is agreed, then both standard conditions require the seller to maintain the policy until completion and if the property suffers damage prior to completion, to hand the insurance proceeds over to the buyer or assign to the buyer all the seller’s rights under the policy.
86
a contract for sale should also stipulate VAT, what are the standard clauses regarding VAT?
(a) The purchase price is exclusive of VAT and VAT will be added on top. (this is SCPCs standard) (b) The purchase price is inclusive of VAT so that VAT, if any, cannot be added on top. (SC but would need to be added as special condition in SCPC) (c) The purchase price is exclusive of VAT, so VAT can be added on top in the unlikely event that the law changes to make an exempt supply chargeable at the standard rate, but the seller is contractually obliged not to opt to tax. (use SCPC contract but incorporate one of the optional standard conditions and disapply the first option)
87
In residential transactions, the lender will usually require a ________________ in the form approved by the Law Society and UK Finance which aims to reduce the risk of a conflict of interest when a solicitor acts for both the lender and the borrower. what does this do? how does the above differ in a commercial transaction?
- certificate of title - confirms to the lender: * there are no legal problems with the property (it has a ‘good and marketable title’) so the lender can safely lend against it * who will own the property once the sale is completed * the completion date when the funds are needed. commercial transaction: - City of London Law Society certificate (more detailed) - special type of report on title which is set out in a series of statements which cannot be altered - if a statement cannot be agreed with, the solicitor makes a disclosure against the statement which sets out how the statement does not apply to the property. - the certificate is prepared by buyers sol - if the information on the certificate is wrong = the lender can sue the firm
88
what steps should be taken by the buyer's sol before the exchange of contracts?
(a) Report to client (in writing) - results of title investigation - searches and enquiries - the terms of the contract - mortgage offer (b) Report to lender (c) Ensure deposit funds are available (d) Check the mortgage offer is in place and that the client has sufficient funds to complete (e) Ensure arrangements are in place for insurance immediately following exchange (f) Contract signed - wet ink - electronic signature provided the person signing the document intends to authenticate it and any execution formalities are satisfied - solicitor can sign the contract on their client’s behalf if they have the client’s express authority to do so. (g) Completion date
89
Before exchanging contracts, both solicitors must obtain their client’s _______________________.
- authority to exchange - in writing - make note on file - if done without authorisation > negligence
90
list the three ways in which exchange of contracts can be done
1. In person, by one solicitor attending the other’s office and handing the contract over. 2. By post, with each solicitor sending their client’s part of the contract by post to the other solicitor’s office. 3. Over the telephone.
91
What are the three methods of completion provided for in the Law Society's Protocols for Completion?
- via telephone - in each, sol gives undertaking to comply Formula A: - ONE sol holds BOTH parts of the contract (which has been signed by buyer + seller) - telephone call effects exchange - the sol dates both docs - sends the part signed by their client to the other sol Formula B: - EACH sol holds their client's signed contract - telephone call to effect exchange - each sol dates - each sol sends their client's signed + dated doc to the other Formula C - mainly residential chain transactions - complex
92
what is the impact of exchange of contracts?
The seller retains the legal title in the property until completion, but holds the beneficial interest on behalf of the buyer.
93
What is required to transfer land?
- deed - sale contract does not transfer the land - just gives the buyer a beneficial interest
94
Both sets of standard conditions list the kinds of incumbrances that must be included in the contract. Which are not included in this list?
mortgages
95
what is the effect of non-disclosure of an incumbrance which affects the property being sold?
- buyer may have right to rescind + damages
96
who is likely to provide a limited title guarantee?
an executor or trustee as they have limited knowledge of the property
97
where are the standard and special conditions found in a standard form sale contract?
middle - standard conditions - these terms will govern the transaction unless the parties have expressly agreed something else - these aren't amended back page - special conditions - drafted to meet the particular requirements of this transaction
98
who usually drafts the contract of sale?
seller
99
how do you know from the official copies whether a property is held as joint tenancy or tenants in common?
if there is a restriction on the register = tenants in common
100
for registered land, which form do you complete to show a mortgage has been or will be discharged upon sale of the property?
DS1
101
what special condition might you include regarding fixtures and chattels?
- if there are any fixtures that are being removed - when they are to be removed - indemnify the new buyer for any damage caused from removals
102
what is the standard condition regarding time for completion?
- 2pm on the allocated day - can be amended via special condition
103
will there be provisions for an indemnity covenant under the standard conditions or do you need to draft a special condition for an indemnity covenant?
- both sets of standard conditions provide where the seller has an ongoing liability in relation to the property > indemnity covenant - no need to insert - most sols include a special condition regardless
104
what do the standard conditions state for VAT for residential property?
- remember residential property = no VAT - SC 1.4 purchase price = inclusive of VAT (because it is expected that no VAT will be charged or paid).
105
what if you wanted to use one of the Law Society formulae for exchange of contracts but there was something you needed to amend in them e.g. the method in which payment could be made or the timescales for posting the docs?
you would need to vary the formula a typical example of this is where the parties want to use the formula to buy comm prop. the SCPC only provide for payment via electronic means so the formula must be varied to allow for this
106
which out of formula A and B is quicker and why?
- B is quicker - formula A, one sol has to send via post to the other sol > then exchange takes place - whereas B, both sols have the signed versions from their clients already > exchange takes place > then post to one another
107
which method of exchange is the most and the least safe?
Personal exchange is the safest method, postal exchange is the least safe method.
108
who will the certificate of title (e.g. Law Society and UK Finance or City of London Law Society) be addressed to?
sometimes = buyer and lender sometimes just the lender
109
what are the main tasks sols undertake in the pre-completion stage?
* Preparation of the transfer deed * Pre- completion searches * Making practical arrangements for completion * Ensuring the finances are in order for completion
110
a transfer deed (TR1) will be drafted before completion. what are the requirements of the transfer deed?
- s52 LPA states that the transfer of a legal estate in land must be by deed - for a deed to be valid in law it must: 1. writing 2. make it clear that it is a deed 3. signed by the parties 4. delivered
111
how can a company execute a deed?
1. using the company seal in accordance with the articles of association 2. having it signed by a director and the secretary, or by two directors of the company, provided that the deed is expressed to be executed by the company 3. having it signed by a single director in the presence of a witness who then attests that signature
112
The seller will always execute the transfer deed in order to transfer the land in the sale of land. in what circumstances would the buyer also execute the deed?
if the buyer is entering into an obligation or making a declaration in the TR1, such as giving an indemnity covenant or declaring a beneficial interest under a trust.
113
The deed used to transfer the whole of registered freehold title is Land Registry Form... The deed used to transfer part of registered freehold title is Land Registry Form...
TR1 TP1
114
how would you go about executing a deed for transfer of unregistered land in a sale/purchase?
it will be subject to first registration so the sols will often use a LR Transfer form or alternatively, a conveyance can be used
115
who is the transfer deed drafted by?
usually the buyer's sol sends it to the seller's sol for agreement immediately after exchange of contracts
116
when completing the transfer deed in preparation for completion, should the sol date the TR1 form?
no - the transfer deed should only be completed upon completion
117
who are pre-completion searches usually carried out by?
the buyer's sol
118
when should pre-completion searches be conducted?
as soon to completion as is possible
119
why are pre-completion searches carried out if they have already been carried out in the investigation of title stage?
- to check nothing has changed since investigation of title e.g. no further incumbrances, no liquidation - to gain priority for the buyer (and lender)
120
There are two types of pre- completion search depending on whether title to the property is registered or unregistered. explain the searches for registered and unregistered land...
REGISTERED: - OS1 (OS1R = form) - search against title number - 30 days priority UREGISTERED: - K15 - search against each owner's name for the duration they owned the land - if any doubt regarding how long they owned for > search back to 1926 - charge for each search - 15 days priority
121
a land registry search completed in the pre-completion stage will confer a priority period over the applicant. what is this, how does it work?
- it provides protection to the applicant against any subsequent entries which may be placed on the register after the date of the search but before the buyer is registered as proprietor - the buyer will take free from any such entries, provided that they submit their application for registration by 12 noon on the last day of the priority period.
122
how does the application to the LR for pre-completion searches change if the buyer is purchasing the property with the aid of a mortgage? why is this the case?
- OS1 should be made in the name of the lender - means the results will confer priority on both the buyer and the lender
123
Pre- completion searches: - To confer priority on the buyer > always OS1 + K15 IN ADDITION > BANKRUPTCY SEARCHES: - How would you check the solvency of both buyer + seller? (both for individual + for a company)
124
what is the protection provided under s. 85 LRA 2002?
- for a buyer of registered land from an individual seller - where no notice or restriction relating to the bankruptcy appears on the registered title, a buyer for value acting in good faith without notice of the bankruptcy petition or adjudication will take good title from the bankrupt seller, even though legal title to the land has vested in the trustee in bankruptcy - if buyer is concerned or transaction of high value > could do individual bankruptcy search on K16
125
when should a company's search be completed?
- as close to completion as possible because there is no priority period - transaction of high value or concerns re solvency > telephone search > Registry of Winding Up Petitions at the Companies Court on the day of completion.
126
how do the buyer and seller agree the practicalities of completion?
- completion information form - buyer's sol sends to seller to complete - most commonly used > TA12 Completion Information and Undertakings
127
what does the TA13 Completion and Undertakings form ask?
asks the seller: * handing over the keys * place and method of completion * the documents to be handed over at completion * the exact amount payable by the buyer on completion - undertaking from seller's sol > redeem the mortgage out of the completion money on completion - usually also ask to send evidence of discharge to the buyer’s solicitor as soon as it is received from the lender
128
If the buyer is financing the purchase with the aid of a mortgage, before releasing the mortgage advance a lender will expect to receive what four things?
1. a CERTIFICATE OF TITLE to confirm that the property is adequate security for the loan being advanced 2. a SOLVENCY SEARCH against the borrowers 3. a clear OS1R in the name of the lender 4. an executed but not completed MORTGAGE DEED
129
Pre- Completion: The solicitor for the buyer will need to send a ____________________________ to the client advising the client of the funds needed to complete. what will this show?
Financial Statement: - the amount that should be forwarded by the buyer to its sol - the balance of the purchase price - any SDLT/ LTT due - registration fee - the amount outstanding for any other disbursements, - the solicitor’s fees - any other amount owing, eg a restrictive covenant insurance policy premium
130
what should the buyer's sol ensure they have finance wise before completion?
the mortgage advance from the lender + the balance of the purchase price from the buyer
130
the standard conditions (for both resi and com prop) require completion monies to be sent in a certain way, what is this?
paid by direct transfer/ electronic means in cleared funds from an account held in the name of a conveyancer at a clearing bank
131
upon receipt of completion money, the seller's sol will complete the transaction by doing what?
- sellers sol dates the TR1 - lender's sol dates the mortgage deed
132
what must sols follow if completion is to take place via post? what is it?
Law Society Code for Completion by Post - involves the SELLER'S SOL ACTING AS AN AGENT of the buyer’s solicitor for the purpose of carrying out the completion procedure (at no cost to the buyer) - the buyer's sol should set out in WRITING what the seller's sol should do on their behalf - the buyer's sol is asking the seller's sol to do whatever they would've done if they had attended the completion in person - so on receipt of completion monies, the seller's sol will carry out the buyer's instructions and complete the transaction - the seller's sol should then contact the buyer's sol and let them know completion has taken place + the docs that go to the buyer's sol will be placed in first class post or DX NOTE: under the Code the seller’s solicitor gives an IMPLIED UNDERTAKING to carry out the buyer’s solicitor’s instructions
133
what is the effect of completion?
REGISTERED LAND: - legal title does not pass to the buyer until the buyer is registered at the Land Registry as proprietor of the land - NOTE this is why it is so important to use a LR charges search which confers a period of priority (because it protects the buyer from the creation of adverse third party rights in the intervening ‘registration gap’) UNREGISTERED LAND: - legal title passes to the buyer on completion
134
list the post-completion steps
1. discharge of the seller's mortgage 2. SDLT/LTT 3. Registration of the new charge at LR 4. Land Registry Application
135
looking at post-completion steps... Once the lender has received the amount required to redeem the mortgage from the seller’s solicitor, what do they do?
* complete DS1 > send to seller's sol > send to buyer's sol * submit an e- DS1 electronic discharge through the Land Registry portal; or * use the Electronic Discharge (ED) system, sending an electronic message to the Land Registry which automatically removes the charge from the register. note - for the latter two, the seller's sol just notifies the buyer's sol that notice of discharge has been given to the LR (just via electronic means)
136
looking at post-completion steps... how long does a buyer who is a company who has purchased a property with aid of a mortgage have to register the charge with CH? what are the consequences of failing to meet this timescale?
- 21 days from completion - gives constructive notice of the mortgage charge to other creditors of the company - time limit cannot be extended without a court order - failure to register = charge void against a liquidator or administrator of the borrower and the borrower’s other creditors - massive effect on lender's security
137
who applies to the Land Registry to have the buyer registered as the registered proprietor of the land in the title?
the buyer's sol
138
- how do you apply to the LR to have a buyer registered as the new registered proprietor of purchased registered land? - what documents should be included in the application? - when should the application to the LR be made?
- on LR form AP1 - if the seller had a mortgage which has been electronically discharged, the charges on the register protecting the mortgage will automatically be removed - but if DS1 used = buyer’s sol must apply for the mortgage to be discharged (can be done via AP1 form) - along with the AP1 should be: 1. certified copy of the transfer 2. the fee 3. SDLT/LTT certificate 4. DS1 (if used) 5. form DI setting out any overriding interests that burden the title (once they are on the register they cease to be overriding) if the buyer has created a new mortgage, the following should also be included: i) certified copy of the mortgage deed ii) if the buyer is a company, certified copy of the certificate of registration issued by CH iii) if the buyer is a company, the solicitor’s / lender’s written confirmation that the enclosed certified copy mortgage deed is the same as the one filed at Companies House and to which the certificate of registration relates. - application should be made within the priority period of the OS1 form
139
how do you apply to the LR to have a buyer registered as the new registered proprietor of purchased unregistered land?
- first registration - within 2 months of completion - form FR1 - docs accompanying app > listed in chronological order on form DL - estimate for registration provided - LR needs to investigate title so it can give the title a class - docs included in the application: 1. all docs which formed the evidence of title supplied by the seller’s solicitor 2. all the buyer’s pre- contract searches and enquiries relating to the title with their replies 3. the contract 4. requisitions on title with their replies 5. all pre- completion search certificates 6. the transfer deed 7. the seller’s mortgage, duly receipted 8. SDLT/ LTT certificate 9. Form DI (overriding interests) if new mortgage: 10. certified copy of the mortgage deed 11. if the buyer is a company, certified copy of the certificate of registration issued by Companies House 12. if the buyer is a company, the solicitor’s / lender’s written confirmation that the enclosed certified copy mortgage deed is the same as the one filed at Companies House and to which the certificate of registration relates.
140
once an application for a new proprietor has been registered on the Land Registry, the LR forward an official copy of the entries on the Register to the buyer's sol confirming the buyer is the new owner. what is the document called?
- Title Information Document (or ‘TID’) - not a document of title - but evidence the buyer is the new owner - sols for buyer + lender should check it to ensure it has been properly registered
141
The exchanged contract will usually contain a date for completion, but if it does not, SC 6.1.1 and SCPC 9.1.1 provide that the completion date is ___________________ after the date of the contract.
20 working days
142
In both the SC and the SCPC, money due on completion must be paid by ______________ and if it is not it, completion takes place the following day
2pm parties can agree to vary this in the contract
143
what do both sets of standard conditions provide for on late completion?
1. time is not of the essence of the contract UNLESS a NOTICE TO COMPLETE has been served - there is no immediate right for the non-defaulting party to terminate or rescind 2. COMPENSATION paid for late completion
144
what is the distinction between the contractual compensation owed to parties for late completion under the standard conditions?
- both sets of standard conditions provide for compensation to be paid DISTINCTION - SCs = both the buyer and the seller can be asked to pay this compensation (SC 7.2) - SCPCs = only the buyer can be required to pay compensation (SCPC 10.3)
145
how is contractual compensation for late completion calculated?
- contract rate specified in the contract - charged on the balance of the purchase price - (less any deposit if the defaulting buyer was the buyer) - period between contractual completion date and actual - calculated at daily rate - if the non-paying party was also responsible for some of the delay = those days are ignored - compensation is payable on completion - remember to divide the amount by 365 to calculate one day then times that by the amount of defaulting days
146
how will common law damages be calculated for late completion?
- putting the claimant in the position it would have been in had the contract been correctly performed - damages for loss naturally flowing from the breach + any reasonably foreseeable consequential losses - e.g. wasted legal costs, putting furniture into storage, the cost of renting another property, the cost of bridging finance and any rebooking removal costs can claim for both contractual compensation and contractual damages BUT NOTE the contractual compensation the innocent party receives will be deducted from the contractual damages
147
what is a notice to complete? how does it work? what effect does it have? what effect does it have on the deposit?
- party who is ready and willing to complete can serve - can only be served after the contractual date for completion - once served = gives the other party 10 working days to complete - if no completion within 10 working days = can rescind contract (but is not obliged to) - if rescinded and the defaulting party was the buyer, the seller is able to forfeit the deposit - if defaulting party was the seller, then the seller must repay the deposit to the buyer
148
when can a contract for the purchase of property be rescinded?
- where the SC / SCPC are incorporated, recission is available in certain circumstances e.g. a) where a party has failed to comply with a notice to complete b) misrepresentation by the seller in a plan or statement in the contract, or in the negotiations leading up to the contract only where: - seller’s error or omission results from fraud or recklessness - the buyer would be obliged to accept a property differing substantially (in quantity, quality or tenure) from what the error or omission had led them to expect note = less serious misrepresentations = just damages
149
if you are a first time residential buyer and dont have to pay SDLT, do you still need to do a SDLT form post completion?
yes - just dont pay any still need SDLT5 form
150
who usually drafts the transfer deed?
buyer's sol - SC 4.3.2
151
what is the time limit for registering the with the LR post completion?
the end of the priority period (30 working days from search date)
152
post completion, a company will have to pay SDLT within 14 days. do they pay the SDLT on the purchase price plus VAT or excluding VAT?
the company will have to pay SDLT on the purchase price PLUS VAT within 14 days of completion.
153
The transfer of property must always be executed by the seller and must also be executed by the buyer where it contains a covenant or declaration on the buyer’s behalf. give an example of a declaration a buyer might make on a transfer deed...
if the buyers want to be co-owners holding the property as tenants in common
154
what are the disadvantages and advantanges of owning a leasehold property?
from a tenants pov: - depreciating asset - landlord specifies what the tenant can and cant do - there will probably be repair obligations in the lease which will involve expenditure by the tenant from a landlords pov: - tenant may not pay the rent - tenant may not look after the property (which could result in depreciation of the landlord's investment) - the income and capital are not guaranteed and are dependent on the market advantages: - it is important for multiple occupancy buildings to have enforceable positive covenants especially regarding repairs (this is difficult to achieve with freehold land) - if the lease is properly drafted, the landlord will be able to recover all expenditure for maintenance and repair from the tenant by way of a service charge paid by the tenant - retains an asset at the end of the lease
155
how does a periodic tenancy work?
- also known as rolling tenancy - continues indefinitely - rolling over automatically at the end of each rental period (e.g., month-to-month) - runs until either party decides to terminate it by giving the other party notice - the notice should be the length of one period of the lease e.g. one month’s notice for a monthly tenancy and one quarter’s notice for a quarterly tenancy - exception to the general rule = yearly tenancy can be terminated on six months’ notice
156
explain the different options for the term of a lease
1. fixed term - lease expires after the fixed term ends 2. periodic tenancy - runs until either party decides to terminate 3. tenancy at will - tenancy may be terminated by either party at any time
157
what is the difference between: i) absolute covenant ii) qualified covenant iii) fully qualified covenant
1. absolute covenant - the tenant absolutely cannot carry out the stated action - the landlord may decide to allow it, either by way of a one- off consent or a permanent variation of the lease, but the landlord has total discretion on the matter 2. qualified covenant - allows the tenant to carry out the stated action, but only if it obtains landlord’s consent first 3. fully qualified covenant - allows the tenant to carry out the stated action if it obtains landlord’s consent first, but goes on to say that the landlord will not be able to withhold consent unreasonably
158
most leases are full repairing and insuring 'FRI'. what benefit does this pose to the landlord. if a lease is not FRI what will it not be?
a ‘clear’ rental stream (all profit) and does not have to dip into it to pay for repairs, maintenance and insurance contributions investment quality’ or ‘institutionally acceptable’
159
a tenant will usually be responsible for the repairs of which elements of a commercial property? what is usually left to a landlord?
tenant = non-structural parts landlord = structural parts and common areas
160
what does case law say about the meaning of a covenant 'to repair'?
a) there MUST BE A DISREPAIR FIRST before the tenant can breach the covenant to repair b) the above may be a problem if the building is BRAND NEW and will inevitably deteriorate from its original pristine condition > the property need not be kept in perfect repair: ‘It need only be put into such a state of repair as renders it fit for the OCCUPATION OF A REASONABLY MINDED TENANT of the class likely to take it’ c) WORKS OF RENEWAL AND IMPROVEMENT go beyond repair. - question of fact and degree and the work the tenant has to carry out depends on the age of the property at the date of the lease d) A repairing covenant does not oblige the tenant to give back to the landlord a property that is ‘WHOLLY DIFFERENT’ from that leased to them, but it can oblige the tenant to remedy an inherent defect in the design and/ or construction of the building if that is the only way to effect the repair
161
why should a tenant be aware of a repair covenant that states the tenant must 'keep' the property in repair?
means to put it into repair even if that involves the tenant putting the building into a better state of repair than when they entered into the lease for example a covenant to ‘keep the property in good condition’ is more onerous, as it can mean that the tenant is obliged to carry out some works, even though there is no actual disrepair
162
who takes out insurance for a leasehold property? landlord or tenant?
- letting of a whole building = tenant could be made solely responsible for insurance - but usually, landlord takes out the insurance, with the cost being passed on to the tenant as a separate insurance rent
163
The insurance provisions in a typical lease of commercial property include the following elements....
1. a LANDLORD'S COVENANT to insure the property against defined risks (the ‘insured risks’) - INSURED RISKS = usually a list of risks in the interpretation part of the lease - in case of any new risks, the list usually end with ‘such other risks as the landlord may reasonably require’ - if the insurance isnt sufficient = liability for any shortfall in the proceeds cause by these are passed on to the tenant in the repairing covenant - should be insured to its ‘full reinstatement value’ 2. A covenant by the tenant to pay for the insurance policy - the 'INSURANCE RENT' = premium for the buildings insurance policy + an associated policy covering the landlord for loss of the annual rent during any period where the tenant is unable to use the building following the occurrence of an insured risk 3. A covenant by the landlord to REINSTATE THE PROPERTY - usually this is expressed as a covenant to use the insurance proceeds to reinstate the property (rather than an absolute obligation to reinstate even if the proceeds are insufficient) 4. RENT SUSPENSION - unless express term to the contrary, rent will continue to be payable even if the property is rendered unusable - the tenant should therefore make sure the lease stipulates otherwise 5. TERMINATION - even if a building is totally destroyed, the doctrine of frustration will only apply in certain circumstances - the lease will often give the landlord the right to terminate the lease IF RESINSTATEMENT PROVES IMPOSSIBLE - the tenant should be able to terminate the lease if the property has NOT BEEN REINSTATED BY THE END OF THE RENT SUSPENSION PERIOD
164
a property should be insured to its 'full reinstatement value'. what does this mean?
- The property should be insured to its ‘full reinstatement value’, otherwise if the property is totally destroyed there will not be enough money to pay for its rebuilding - Full reinstatement value includes costs of demolition and site clearance, professional fees (eg architects, surveyors etc) and an allowance for inflation.
165
what is a break clause?
allows both parties to terminate so long as certain conditions are met
166
how do the tenant's repair covenant and the landlord's insurance covenant interplay, to benefit the landlord if the property is damaged?
- through tenant paying for insurance alongside rent, landlord gets: i) £ from insurance company to bring property back to full reinstatement value ii) any insurance premium covered by the tenant- iii) an equivalent sum to what was the tenant's rent (tenant pays for loss of rent insurance for landlord)
167
what are the different kinds of alterations that may be covered by the lease? which are usually allowed by the landlord, which are not?
* Alterations affecting the structure and exterior of the building (usually absolute covenants) * Non- structural interior alterations (usually qualified covenants) * Alterations affecting service media such as heating, lighting, communications systems * Demountable partitioning, such as that used to separate open plan floors into different ‘rooms’
168
It is common for a lease to contain ABSOLUTE COVENANTS in relation to structural and exterior alterations. are there any ways around this for a tenant? think LCD
- s 3 LTA > enable to carry out ‘improvements’ (even where absolute prohibition) - serve a notice on the landlord detailing its proposals - the landlord has 3 months within which to object - if objects, the tenant has the right to apply to the court - the court can authorise the improvements if they : i) ADD to the LETTING VALUE of the property ii) are REASONABLE AND SUITABLE TO THE CHARACTER of the property iii) DO NOT DIMINISH THE VALUE OF ANY OF THE OTHER PROPERTY of the landlord - a landlord can offer to carry out the works itself in return for a reasonable increase in the rent - tenant = under no obligation to accept an offer - if tenant doesnt want to accept > can withdraw the notice - if withdrawn > landlord has no right to carry out the works and increase the rent - if the tenant rejects the landlord’s offer = court cannot give the tenant authority to do the works itself - if the landlord does not offer to carry out the works itself, or object to the improvements within three months (or if the court authorises the work) = tenant may lawfully carry them out - S 1 LTA 1927 > tenant can claim compensation for improvements that ‘add to the letting value of the holding’
169
what is a licence to alter?
a separate document from the lease containing the consent to make alterations and the conditions for the alterations
170
s 19(2) LTA 1927 where there is a QUALIFIED covenant against making 'improvements' to a property = the landlord cannot unreasonably withhold its consent. what is meant by 'improvements'?
works that increase the VALUE OR USEFULNESS of the property to the tenant (even if the improvements will result in the reduction in the value of the landlord’s reversionary interest)
171
what is a user clause? how does it work?
- landlord may impose a tenant's covenant to keep a property for a single use (or in a use class) - landlord’s consent can unreasonably withheld for user covenants - the landlord cannot charge a fine or an increased rent as a condition of giving consent (provided no structural alteration is involved - see s3 LTA)
172
what is alienation? what does it include?
- tenant transfers their leasehold interest to a third party - covenant to prevent this - landlord chose existing tenant because of their 'strength of covenant' alienation includes: * assignment * underletting (also known as subletting) * charging (also known as mortgaging) * sharing occupation (allowing a third party in while continuing to occupy, perhaps under a licence or concession arrangement) * parting with possession (a catch- all term which covers assignment and underletting but also includes informal arrangements which may be difficult to classify)
172
how does assignment work?
- the current tenant (the "assignor") transfers their entire legal interest in a property to a new tenant (the "assignee") - with the landlord's consent - the assignee takes over the lease and becomes responsible for all obligations
173
what are three statutory provisions that are relevant to assignment covenants? what do they say?
19(1)(a) LTA 1927 - qualified covenant > fully qualified covenant - restricts the landlord's ability to unreasonably withhold consent to the assignment or subletting 19(1A) LTA 1927: - allows for the landlord and tenant to agree in advance conditions and circumstances in which it would not be unreasonable for the landlord to refuse consent - the effect = such pre-agreed conditions and circumstances are deemed reasonable e.g. T must give AGA as a condition of LL giving consent s. 1 LTA 1988: - where the tenant has made a written application for consent, the landlord must within a reasonable time: a) give consent, except in a case where it is reasonable not to give consent b) serve on the tenant written notice of its decision + reasons for withholding + any conditions on the consent
174
The Court of Appeal laid down a number of guidelines on the issue of the landlord’s reasonableness under s 19(1)(a) LTA 1927. (turning qualified covenant to assign into fully qualified covenant > must not unreasonably withhold consent) what do the guidelines say about: i) what factors the landlord should consider when deciding ii) whether the landlord needs to provide justification for its decision iii) whether it is reasonable to refuse based on the proposed purpose of the new assignee iv) whether the landlord should consider the tenant's interests, or just their own
- not entitled to refuse its consent to an assignment on GROUNDS WHICH HAVE NOTHING TO DO with the relationship of landlord and tenant in regard to the subject matter of the lease - it is UNNCESSARY for the landlord to prove that the conclusions which led it to refuse to consent were JUSTIFIED, if they were conclusions which might be reached by a reasonable person in the circumstances - may be reasonable for the landlord to refuse its consent to an assignment on the ground of the PURPOSE FOR WHICH THE PROPOSED ASSIGNEE INTENDS TO USE THE PREMISES, even though that purpose is not forbidden by the lease - a landlord is bound to consider only its own relevant interests when deciding whether to refuse consent to an assignment - however, it would be unreasonable for a landlord not to CONSIDER THE DETRIMENT which would be suffered by the tenant if consent were to be refused, if that detriment would be EXTREME AND DISPROPORTIONATE in relation to the benefit gained by the landlord. - is a question of fact
175
will a landlord's refusal to give consent to assignment under s. 19 (1) (a) LTA 1927, be deemed unreasonable in the following: * landlord has refused consent in an attempt to obtain some advantage for itself * minor breaches of the repairing covenant * premises had been on the market for 18 months, the rent was significant and the slight harm to the landlord would be outweighed by prejudice to the tenant.
yes all unreasonable
176
how does underletting work?
- a lease created by someone who is already a tenant - landlord's consent > licence to underlet tripartite doc (head landlord, head tenant, sub tenant) - there are two leases in existence in relation to the same property = a headlease and an underlease - an underlease is an estate in land - an underlease must be for a shorter term than the headlease out of which it is created, even if just by one day - otherwise the transaction is an assignment of the headlease rather than the creation of a new underlease - usually obligation in the licence to underlet, that the head tenant will pay the head landlord's costs for the underletting process
177
why might a tenant decide to underlet as opposed to assign?
- if the tenant would like to get the property back again at some time in the future - if the tenant only wants to dispose of part of the property - also more suitable where the landlord has concerns about about the financial strength of the proposed new occupier, so will not give consent for an assignment of the headlease NOTE - it may be that the tenant would prefer to assign the lease, but cannot find anyone willing to take it. - e.g rent levels have been dropping and the rent reserved by the tenant’s lease is too high - take underlease at lower rent - at least some income + other property-related costs (insurance) are off- loaded onto the undertenant.
178
what is a landlord's main concern about underletting?
Although legally the headtenant will remain liable to the landlord for the performance of the tenant’s covenants under the lease, in reality it is the undertenant who will be in occupation and who will have physical control of the property.
179
which statutory provisions are relevant to underletting?
19(1)(a) LTA1927: - turns a qualified covenant into a fully qualified covenant - restricts the landlord's ability to unreasonably withhold consent to the assignment or subletting of a lease s. 1 LTA1988: - where the tenant has made a written application for consent, the landlord must within a reasonable time: a) give consent, except in a case where it is reasonable not to give consent b) serve on the tenant written notice of its decision + reasons for withholding + any conditions
180
what are some common conditions that may exist in the alienation covenant in regards to subletting?
1. the TERMS of the underlease MIRROR those of the headlease 2. the annual RENT RESERVED by the underlease is at least as high as the annual rent reserved by the headlease and they must be reviewed at the same time 3. that any underletting must EXCLUDE s 24– 28 in Part II LTA 1954, which give business tenants the statutory right to stay on the property and renew their leases at the expiry of the contractual term 4. that the undertenant enters into a 'DIRECT COVENANT' with the landlord to perform the tenant’s covenants in the underlease and the headlease (excluding annual rent payable) - this is necessary because ordinarily there is no liability between the landlord and the undertenant - the direct covenant creates contractual relationship (means landlord can sue them)
181
if a lease is silent on whether rent is paid in advance or in arrears, when will the rent be payable?
if the lease is silent > rent in arrears (meaning after the rent period has elapsed)
182
what are the 4 different types of rent review clauses?
1. fixed increase - at various intervals in the term, rent increases by fixed amounts - simplicity - but not often used > difficult to predict rental levels in future 2. index-linked - linked to external index e.g. Retail Price Index - allows rent to be altered in line with inflation - but doesn't track the property market specifically - usually have 'a cap and a collar' = limits % increase + ensures min. increase 3. tenant's receipts - from use of the property - turnover, profits, how much they make from subletting - tracks the tenant's actual financial health - incentivises LL to do all it can to increase tenant's trade - business may be failing 4. open market rent review - rent adjusted at regular intervals - usually every 3-5 years - in reference to the open market rental value of the premises
183
what are the two main factors which are considered during an open-market rent review?
the physical property and the terms of the lease itself
184
what issues may arise with an open-market rent review clause?
- not always easy to assess the reality of the situation - e.g. if the premises are dilapidated and run- down, the tenant might expect the rental value be assessed accordingly - however, if the premises are dilapidated and run- down because the tenant is in breach of its repairing obligations under the lease, it would not be fair that the rent should be reduced because then the tenant would be profiting from its breach
185
a lease will need to set out a process for how each rent review will be carried out, including: a) level of rent b) frequency of review c) instigation of review d) independent determination what do the above provide?
a) level of rent - the rent review clause may be (and often is) upwards- only, meaning that rent will either stay the same on review, or increase b) frequency of review - typically set every three or five years, on the anniversary of the commencement of the lease c) instigation of review d) independent determination - whichever method is used to instigate the review (formal or informal), should the parties fail to agree the revised rent, the lease should make provision for the matter to be referred to an independent third party, usually appointed through the Royal Institute of Chartered Surveyors
186
In most leases with an open market rent review, is time of the essence?
- either party can instigate the review - time is not usually of the essence - where the reviewed rent is agreed or determined after the relevant review date, the lease will provide that the tenant continues to pay rent at the old rate and pays any additional amount to the landlord together with interest (at a nonpunitive rate) to compensate the landlord for the delay
187
When negotiating the terms of a lease, surveyors who are RICS members must comply with certain mandatory requirements in the ____________________________ and only depart from its other best practice statements with _________________________________
RICS Code for leasing business premises justifiable good reason examples of mandatory requirements under the code: 1. Lease negotiations must be approached in a constructive and collaborative manner. 2. Any party not represented by an RICS member or other property professional must be advised of the existence of the code and must be recommended to obtain professional advice. 3. Transaction terms must be recorded in writing, subject to contract and must summarise specified details as a minimum.
188
How could a landlord find out about a proposed tenant's ‘strength of covenant’, ie the tenant’s ability to pay the rent and perform the covenants? what might the landlord request in evidence of this?
* references from a previous landlord * guarantee obtained from the parent company, a bank involved in financing the transaction or from one or more of the directors * a rent deposit (a sum of money deposited with the landlord on terms which enable the landlord to withdraw sums if rent due under lease is unpaid).
189
Where the lease is an underlease, the scope for negotiating the document will be much more restricted. Why is this?
it is likely that the headlease requires that the terms of the underlease mirrors the terms of the headlease
190
what is an agreement for lease?
- a legally binding contract between a landlord and a tenant that outlines the intention to enter into a lease agreement in the future - useful where there is going to be a delay between agreeing the lease/ underlease and actually granting it but one (or both) of the parties requires the other to be bound into the transaction e.g. the landlord is in the process of constructing the property and wants to know that the tenant is bound to take the lease on completion of the works so that there will be rental income to help offset the building costs
191
who drafts the agreement for lease? what should be attached to it? when must it be provided to the tenant?
- by the landlord’s solicitor (like in the sale of freehold land) - the final agreed lease should be attached to the agreement for lease with an obligation in the agreement for the tenant to take a lease/underlease in that form on the date of completion - must be provided to the tenant AT LEAST 5 WORKING DAYS BEFORE COMPLETION DATE - incumbrances should be disclosed - the attached lease/underlease should contain an indemnity in respect of future breaches of any covenants affecting the title
192
what things would the landlord's sol need to do in the deduction and investigation of title stage of granting a lease?
- ensure the landlord's title - where the property is subject to an existing mortgage, the mortgage will frequently contain a prohibition or restriction on the borrower/ landlord’s ability to grant a lease of the property so the lender must be contacted and its permission obtained before the transaction proceeds
193
what things would the tenant's sol need to do in the deduction and investigation of title stage of granting a lease?
1. investigation of title - done in same way as for freehold property 2. deduction of title - NOTE > although most landlords are happy to deduce their title, under the general law a tenant is not entitled to call for deduction of the freehold title UNLESS the transaction is the grant of a lease for a term of MORE THAN 7 years - where this is the case and there is to be an agreement for lease, SC 8.2.4 (SCPC 11.2.4) requires the landlord to deduce such title as would enable the tenant to obtain registration with an absolute title at the Land Registry - dont need to check title, but still check headlease itself and the official copies for the headlease Where the headlease is unregistered: * the general law ENTITLES the undertenant to call for the headlease and all subsequent assignments under which the headlease has been held for the last 15 years * under the general law, the undertenant is only entitled to call for deduction of the freehold title where the transaction is the grant of a lease for a term of MORE THAN 7 YEARS NOTE - If unable to comply, the headtenant will need to exclude this requirement by a special condition in the contract
194
summarise the pre-completion formalities of the granting of a lease
- normally prepared in two identical parts = lease (executed by the landlord) and counterpart (executed by the tenant) - landlord's sol drafts the lease so: 1) landlord signs lease in readiness for completion 2) counterpart should be sent to tenants sol at least five working days before contractual completion date if SC 8.2.5 or SCPC 11.2.5 apply - on completion > signed copies of lease + counterpart are exchanged - lease = legal estate in land so needs to comply with the relevant authorities (execute a deed)
195
what should happen at the completion stage of a lease? what should the landlord receive from the tenant? what should the landlord give to the tenant?
the landlord should receive from the tenant: (a) the counterpart lease/ underlease executed by the tenant/ undertenant; (b) any premium payable for the grant (less any deposit paid on exchange of contracts); (c) an apportioned sum representing rent payable in advance under the lease/ underlease. the landlord should give to the tenant: (a) the lease/ underlease executed by the landlord; (b) if not already done, properly marked or certified copies of the freehold title deeds (unregistered land only); (c) where relevant, a certified copy of the consent of the landlord’s lender to the transaction. note - on the grant of an underlease = need licence to underlet
196
how does SDLT operate on the grant of a lease (or underlease)?
- land transaction return must be filed with HMRC - SDLT payable on premium paid + any rent reserved - SDLT charged on the premium as it would be in com prop - Net Present Value formula just for the rental element - how much is payable for the duration of the lease (plus VAT) - discount factor of 3.5% - reflects the fact that future rent received will have a lower value than if it was received today
197
what post-completion steps should be taken after granting a lease regarding registration?
1. A legal lease for 7 YRS OR LESS is NOT CAPABLE of being registered with its own title at the LR - will take effect as an overriding interest - in unreg land a legal lease is binding on all subsequent owners of the land, irrespective of notice 2. A lease for OVER 7 YRS MUST be registered with its own separate title, regardless of whether the landlord’s title is registered. 3. It is possible to NOTE LEASES OF OVER 3 YRS against the landlord’s title voluntarily (3yrs or less = cannot be noted on the landlord's title) - must be made within the priority period conferred by the OSR1 search - if unregistered = app for first registration and must be made within 2 months of the grant of the lease
198
what is a self- help/ Jervis v Harris clause?
- contractual remedy for the landlord - allowing the landlord to recover the cost of repairs as A DEBT and not a damages claim - this way the the landlord is able to avoid the statutory limitations on pursuing damages claims imposed by the 1927 and 1938 Acts - allows the landlord to enter the property to check compliance with the tenant’s repair covenant - if breach > landlord serve NOTICE specifying the works required to remedy the breach - if the tenant fails to start the work within a specified period after service of the landlord’s notice, or is not proceeding diligently with those works, the landlord may enter, carry out the works and RECOVER ALL COSTS from the tenant as a debt.
199
a lease can still be terminated at common law, even where the tenant is not in breach of any of the covenants in the lease. list the ways in which leases come to an end at common law?
1. effluxion of time: - when a fixed-term lease ends (not notice is required) 2. notice to quit 3. surrender 3. merger
200
explain how a lease is terminated at common law by notice to quit
- periodic tenancies - serve notice to quit - yearly tenancy = 6 months notice at the end of a completed year of the tenancy - all other = one full period’s notice (ie one quarter, month, etc) expiring at the end of a completed period of the tenancy - where premises wholly or partly occupied as dwelling > not less than 4 weeks - e.g. if a tenant has a monthly tenancy which starts on the first of each month and the landlord wants to serve a notice to quit on 14 August, the earliest date the landlord can specify for expiry of the notice is 30 September
201
explain how a lease is terminated at common law via surrender
- where the tenant yields up the lease to the landlord who accepts the surrender - a surrender can only be achieved if BOTH the landlord and the tenant AGREE TO IT - on surrender, the lease is said to merge in the landlord’s reversion and is extinguished - to be legal, surrender MUST BE BY DEED (LPA 1925, s 52).
202
explain how a lease is terminated at common law via merger
- It is the opposite of surrender - This occurs where the tenant acquires the immediate reversion to the lease (ie acquires the landlord’s estate in land) - It can also occur where a third party acquires both the lease and the reversion. - once the lease and the reversion are with the tenant or third party, the lease automatically merges with the reversion and is extinguished (unless the tenant/ third party expressly preserves the lease in the documentation)
203
what effect does the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 have on termination of a lease?
A tenancy protected by the 1954 Act may continue until it is terminated in accordance with the provisions of the Act. So, a fixed term business lease will not necessarily end at the expiration of the fixed term and a periodic business lease will not necessarily be determined by service of a notice to quit (i.e a common law method of termination)
204
when will the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 apply?
1. must be a tenancy (not a licence) 2. of a property which is occupied by the tenant (personally, or through the medium of an agent or manager) 3. for business purposes
205
which type of business tenancy do not fall under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954?
1. tenancies at will 2. Fixed- term tenancies not exceeding six months - but the Act will apply where there has been a succession of sixth month tenancies - doesnt apply where only two six month tenancies with no right to renew - tenant cant have been in occupation for more than 12 months at the end 3. certain types of business lease such as tenancies of agricultural holdings, farm business tenancies and mining leases 4. where the landlord and tenant have agreed to contract out of its protections - statutory notice procedure must be strictly followed before the start of the lease in order for it to be effective
206
where a landlord and tenant have agreed to contract our of the protections of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, the landlord must comply with struct statutory notice procedures. what are they?
- landlord must give the tenant notice in a prescribed form - warns the tenant that they are agreeing to a lease without security of tenure - advises them to obtain professional advice - tenant must then make a declaration in a prescribed form that they have received the notice and agree that the lease should be contracted out - if the tenant is given the notice less than 14 days before the grant of the lease, the tenant’s declaration must be made in the form of a statutory declaration before an independent solicitor - a reference to the service of the notice and the tenant’s declaration must be contained or endorsed on the lease itself 14 DAYS FROM NOTICE BEING GIVEN (NOT MAKING DECLARATION)
207
Tenancy will continue until terminated in accordance with the 1954 Act and even then, the tenant has a right to apply to court for a new tenancy which can only be opposed by the landlord on one of the seven statutory grounds contained in s 30 of the 1954 Act. what are the 7 statutory grounds?
The 1954 Act provides for only seven methods of termination: 1) by the service of a landlord’s notice under s 25 2) by the service of a tenant’s request for a new tenancy under s 26 3) forfeiture 4) surrender 5) in the case of a periodic tenancy, by the tenant giving the landlord a notice to quit 6) in the case of a fixed- term lease, by the tenant serving three months’ written notice on the landlord under s 27, so long as the notice does not expire before the contractual expiry date 7) in the case of a fixed- term lease, by the tenant ceasing to be in occupation for business purposes at the end of the lease under s 27(1A) (effluxion of time)
208
what is meant by 'security of tenure' in a lease?
Security of tenure under the 1954 Act means the right for the tenant to stay in the property after the expiry of the contractual term and to apply for a new tenancy, which can only be denied on certain limited statutory grounds set out in s 30 of the 1954 Act.
209
a licence to assign will not be finalised until completion, but what will the assignor need to check at the pre-exchange of contracts stage?
that the landlord will agree to the assignment in principle
210
who usually pays the legal and professional service costs included in the landlord reviewing the licence to assign?
- landlord's sol usually requires an undertaking from the assignor's (buyer's) sols to pay the legal / prof services costs - the undertaking should be limited to reasonable costs incurred + a cap on costs should also be sought
211
The landlord may require the assignee to provide a ____________ as a condition of the consent and/ or the assignor to enter into an __________________ to guarantee the performance of the tenant’s covenants by the assignee before consenting to the assingment of a lease.
guarantor authorised guarantee agreement
212
The landlord’s consent must be given by or on completion of the assignment, otherwise the assignor is likely to be in breach of the assignment covenant in the lease. The contract can deal with this two in different ways, depending on which set of standard conditions are used... explain under the SCs...
- either party may rescind the contract by notice if : i) the landlord's consent has not been given 3 working days before the completion date or ii) if, by that time, consent has been given subject to a condition to which the buyer reasonably objects - technically the above allows exchange of contracts without having obtained the landlord's consent to assignment - but where timing of completion of the transaction is v important it is safest not to exchange until the landlord's consent has been obtained
213
The landlord’s consent must be given by or on completion of the assignment, otherwise the assignor is likely to be in breach of the assignment covenant in the lease. The contract can deal with this two in different ways, depending on which set of standard conditions are used... explain under the SCPCs...
- if the landlord’s consent has not been obtained by the completion date, completion is postponed until 5 working days after the assignor notifies the buyer that consent has been given [check this in the book] - the contract may not be rescinded until 6 months have passed since the original completion date - either party can then rescind by serving notice on one another - if timing of completion is important, it is safest not to exchange until the landlord’s consent has been obtained
214
what is the purpose of a licence to assign? why do we need them?
- for the landlord to give consent to the assignment - otherwise breach of alienation covenant
215
who drafts the licence to assign?
- landlord's sol - landlord executes original licence + assignor executes counterpart - needs to be a deed if covenants entered into
216
who signs the licence to assign?
- If the assignor and assignee are to enter into covenants in the licence then all three (ie landlord, assignor and assignee) will be parties to the licence, which must be in the form of a deed - often the licence is prepared in triplicate - any guarantors of the assignee or assignee will be required to join in
217
a typical licence to assign will contain which components?
(a) The landlord grants consent to the assignor to assign the lease to the assignee - Often this consent will be time- limited (eg three months) because the landlord has no control over when the assignment takes place and the assignee’s financial position can change in a short time (b) If the lease was granted on or after 1 January 1996, the assignor will typically give an AGA to the landlord (c) If the lease was granted before 1 January 1996, a direct covenant by the assignee to the landlord to observe and perform the covenants in the lease for the remainder of the term (d) the assignor agrees to pay the landlord’s legal and professional costs
218
an AGA will usually contain which covenants by the assignor?
(a) guaranteeing that the assignee will perform the tenant’s covenants in the lease, including the covenant to pay rent (b) promising to perform such covenants if the assignee does not (c) indemnifying the landlord for the assignee’s failure to pay rent or to observe the other covenants (d) promising to take a new lease if the liability of the assignee is disclaimed on insolvency.
219
what should the assignor's solicitor check when investigating and deducing title?
1. the superior freehold title 2. the leasehold title 3. any covenants or easements affecting the freehold (as these will also bind the leasehold) - the assignor's sol should always provide the assignee’s solicitor with a copy of the lease and any licence permitting assignment to the current and previous tenants
220
would the superior freehold title need to be deduced by the assignor's sol in the following situations? 1. where the assignor's lease is registered with absolute title 2. where the lease is registered with good leasehold title 3. the assignor's lease is unregistered
1. REGISTERED WITH ABSOLUTE TITLE: - the title to the lease is already guaranteed by the LR = no need to investigate the title to the freehold 2. REGISTERED WITH GOOD LEASEHOLD TITLE: - no guarantee to the soundness of the freehold title - the assignee will try to insist for the deduction of the freehold title (although not entitled under law to do so) - if the freehold is registered either party could make a search under the open register rules - if unregistered, same method for the deduction in freehold land NOTE - neither set of standard conditions require the assignor to deduce the freehold title, so this must be added as a special condition 3. ASSIGNOR'S LEASE IS UNREGISTERED: - where unregistered, the assignee is entitled to call for the lease and all assignments under which that lease has been held during the last 15 years, but not for evidence of the freehold title - Without deduction of the freehold title, unless the freehold is already registered with absolute title, the assignee will only obtain a good leasehold title on registration of the lease at the Land Registry following completion, which may be unacceptable to the assignee and/ or any lender
221
an assignee's sol should make the same pre-contract enquiries and searches as they would on a freehold property. which additional enquiries/searches should be made for the assignment of the lease?
the assignee's sol should ask to see the: 1. insurance policy relating to the property 2. a copy of a receipt for the last payment of annual rent due under the lease - checking the assignor is not in breach of the lease; if there are any outstanding breaches the landlord will be able to enforce the breach against the assignee NOTE - where the lease has only a short period left unexpired, that the buyer may choose not to carry out some or all searches, as the risk does not justify the cost involved
222
In order to transfer legal title to an estate in land, it is necessary to do so by deed. In the case of an assignment of a lease, the transfer deed is sometimes called a ‘deed of assignment’, but this document has the same effect and function as any other transfer deed. who is this prepared by? which prescribed forms will be used?
- prepared by the assignee's solicitor a) assignment of a registered lease (irrespective of how long it has left to run) = TR1 b) assignment of unregistered lease: - a lease exceeding 7 years will trigger compulsory first registration, so TR1 is used - a lease for 7 years or less = deed of assignment (will not trigger first registration)
223
which pre-completion searches should be undertaken for the assignment of a lease?
a) registered lease = OS1 - 30 days priority b) unregistered lease = - K15 land charges search - against the name of the assignor - checking no adverse entries have been made since the pre- exchange land charges search - priority period of 15 days c) same rules apply re company searches as do in freehold property
224
explain how apportionment works as a pre-completion step for the assignment of a lease
- assignor will usually have paid rent in advance - unless completion takes place on a day when the annual rent become due under the lease, it will be necessary for the instalment to be apportioned on completion, so that the assignee reimburses the assignor for the period from completion until the next rent day - may also be other outgoings for which the assignor wants to claim reimbursement e.g. insurance premium - the assignor should supply a completion statement which shows the amounts due and explains how they have been calculated - copies of the receipts or demands on which the apportionments are based should also be supplied with the completion statement, so that the assignee can check the apportioned sums
225
how is the assignment of a lease completed?
- if there is a premium to pay on the assigment (known as balance of the purchase price) - apportionment - any of the following relevant docs: (a) the lease (b) the transfer deed (TR1 or deed of assignment) (c) the licence to assign executed by the landlord (d) evidence of the freehold title in accordance with the contract (e) evidence of discharge of the assignee’s mortgage (f) copies of duplicate notices served by the assignor and its predecessors on the landlord in accordance with a covenant in the lease requiring the landlord to be notified of any dispositions (g) insurance policy (or copy if insurance is effected by the landlord) and receipt (or copy) relating to the last premium due (h) receipt for rent (and other outgoings for which the assignor wishes to claim reimbursement).
226
what should the assignee give to the assignor on completion?
(a) money due in accordance with the completion statement (b) duly executed counterpart licence to assign (c) a release of deposit (only likely where the assignee is paying a premium)
227
what are the post-completion steps of the assignment of a lease?
1. SDLT/LTT - payable on the purchase price (if any), but not on the rent reserved by the lease 2. REGISTERED LEASE - the assignment must be registered at the LR within the priority period conferred by the OS1 3. UNREGISTERED LEASE - An unregistered lease which, at the date of the transfer to the assignee, still has over seven years of the term unexpired will need to be registered at the Land Registry within two months of the assignment or will be void in respect of the legal estate. - If the lease has seven years or less unexpired, it is incapable of registration with separate title.
228
post-completion steps... the landlord must be given __________ of the assignment
landlord must be given notice of the assignment (this is a standard provision) the landlord should be asked to sign one copy of the notice as acknowledgement of receipt and return the receipted copy to the sender to be kept with the title deeds
229
will a landlord be unreasonable in refusing consent where it is anticipated the assignment of the lease would result in a breach of the user covenant by the assignee?
- usually refusal on this ground alone may be considered unreasonable (unless absolute covenant)
230
how could a landlord undertake due diligence on an assignee?
references from: (a) a current landlord; (b) the assignee’s bank; (c) the assignee’s employer; (d) a professional person such as an accountant or solicitor; (e) a person or company with whom the assignee regularly trades; and (f) three years’ audited accounts in the case of a company or self- employed person or partnership.
231
Security of tenure under the 1954 Act means the right for the tenant to stay in the property after the expiry of the contractual term and to apply for a new tenancy, which can only be denied on certain limited statutory grounds set out in s 30 of the 1954 Act. one of the methods = by the service of a landlord’s notice under s 25 explain how this is done
- landlord wants property back - or new lease with higher rent - the landlord must indicate its proposals as to the terms of a new lease in the notice - if the landlord opposes the renewal of the tenancy, the s 25 notice must state the s 30 grounds - served between 6 and 12 months before the contractual expiry date - must state the date upon which the landlord wants the tenancy to end - cannot be earlier than the date the tenancy could have been terminated under the common law e.g. the date cannot be earlier than the expiry of a fixed term - but note it does not have to coincide with the exact date of when the fixed term expires in other words, you dont lose the ability to serve a s.25 notice if there isnt six months, the missing months just get added on
232
explain the court's involvement in a s 25 notice
IF LANDLORD INDICATES IN S.25 NOTICE THEY DONT WANT TO RENEW THE LEASE: - tenant must apply to the court before the expiry of the s 25 notice, or they will lose their rights under the 1954 Act - the landlord can pre-empt the tenant’s application to court by applying for an order to terminate the lease on the grounds stated in its s 25 notice (but not if an application has already been made by the tenant asking for the lease to be renewed) IF LANDLORD INDICTES THEY WILL NOT OPPOSE THE GRANT OF A NEW LEASE: - parties will enter into negotiations for the grant of a new lease - the tenant should still apply to court within the time limit to safeguard their position - this time limit can be extended by agreement between the parties, eg where they are near to agreement on the terms of a new lease and wish to avoid the expense of court proceedings - app is usually made to the county court
233
Security of tenure under the 1954 Act means the right for the tenant to stay in the property after the expiry of the contractual term and to apply for a new tenancy, which can only be denied on certain limited statutory grounds set out in s 30 of the 1954 Act. one of the methods = by the service of a s 26 request explain how this is done
- if a protected tenant wants to remain in the property: 1. do nothing 2. serve s.26 request - brings the current tenancy to an end and constitutes a request for a new tenancy - s 26 request must contain: i) the date on which the tenant wants the new lease to begin ii) must contain all the tenant's proposals for a new tenancy - give LL 6 and 12 months’ notice of the date they want the new tenancy to start - date of new tenancy cannot be earlier than the end of the current one
234
when would the court become involved in a s 26 request from a tenant to renew a lease
- if the landlord wishes to oppose the grant of a new tenancy, it must serve a COUNTER-NOTICE on the tenant - WITHIN 2 MONTHS of the service of the tenant’s s 26 request stating the s 30 ground(s) of opposition - the application must be made prior to the commencement date of the new tenancy specified in the tenant’s s 26 request, unless the landlord agrees an extension of this time limit - the landlord can pre- empt the tenant’s application to court by applying for an order to terminate the lease on the grounds stated in its counter- notice (but not if an application has already been made by the tenant asking for the lease to be renewed)
235
If the landlord opposes the renewal of the tenancy, its s 25 notice or counter- notice to a s 26 request must state on which of the seven specified grounds under s 30 of the 1954 Act it does so. what are the landlord's seven specified grounds for termination under s.30?
(a) Tenant’s failure to REPAIR (b) Tenant’s PERSISTENT delay in paying RENT (c) Tenant’s SUBSTANTIAL breach of OTHER obligations (d) Landlord has offered ALTERNATIVE ACCOMODATION (which must be suitable to the tenant’s needs and on reasonable terms) (e) Tenancy is an underletting of PART (rarely used) (f) Landlord intends to DEMOLISH OR RECONSTRUCT and could not reasonably do so without obtaining possession (g) Landlord intends to occupy the holding for its OWN BUSINESS OR AS RESIDENCE
236
which of the s.30 1954 seven specified grounds are discretionary?
(a) (b) (c) and (e) = discretionary so the court will decide whether or not to grant the tenant a new lease - note it is not sufficient for the landlord just to ESTABLISH THE GROUND, it ALSO has to show that the tenant OUGHT NOT TO BE GRANTED A NEW TENANCY in view of the facts giving rise to the ground - opposition applications to the court are expensive based on the above
237
which of the s.30 1954 seven specified grounds are mandatory?
(d) (f) and (g) landlord simply has to prove that it has offered alternative accommodation or intends to occupy itself
238
what are the requirements for ground (f) of the s.30 seven specified grounds in the 1954 Act? fsp
Ground (f) = landlord intends to demolish or reconstruct and could not reasonably do so without obtaining possession the landlord must show on the termination of the tenancy: i) it has a FIRM AND SETTLED INTENTION to carry out the relevant work (eg that it has obtained the necessary planning permission and the financial arrangements are in place); and ii) it intends to DEMOLISH OR RECONSTRUCT the premises (or a substantial part of them), or to CARRY OUT SUBSTANTIAL WORKS of construction on the holding or a part of it; and iii) it CANNOT reasonably carry out the work WITHOUT OBTAINING POSSESSION
239
when looking at the seven specified grounds under s.30 1954 Act, under what circumstances can ground (g) be relied upon by a landlord?
ground (g) = landlord intends to occupy the holding for its own business or as a residence - LL must have owned their interest for at least 5 YEARS before the ending of the current tenancy - LL must have a FIRM AND SETTLED INTENTION - must demonstrate at the date of the court hearing that it has considered and taken PRACTICAL STEPS TO OCCUPY the property - must also have a REASONABLE PROSPECT of achieving its intention, although it does not have to show that its business will be a success in that location
240
How will the terms of the new lease be agreed between a LL and protected tenant following the service of a s.25 or s.26 notice? - what kind of lease is the tenant entitled to? - how does this differ for the LL?
- usually decided between parties - if not > court decides - likely the new terms will be v. similar to old - court considers old lease + relevant circumstances 1. tenant entitled to tenancy of 'holding' i.e. property comprised IN THE CURRENT TENANCY, but EXCLUDING any part not occupied by the tenant (those parts which the tenant has UNDERLET) 2. landlord entitled to tenancy of WHOLE of the originally demised property (including the parts the tenant has underletted) 3. DURATION must be REASONABLE BUT CANNOT EXCEED 15 YRS 4. the term of the new lease will NOT COMMENCED UNTIL 3 MONTHS AFTER the proceedings are ‘finally disposed of’ (ie when the time limit for appeal has elapsed, so four weeks after the order) - the new lease will thus commence three months and four weeks after the order 5. the rent is OPEN MARKET
241
the terms of a new lease are usually negotiated between the parties, but if they are determined by the court, the renewal lease is likely to be on the same terms and conditions as the old lease. is there anything the landlord or the tenant can do if it finds the terms of the new lease ordered by the court unacceptable?
-TENANT can APPLY for the order to be REVOKED - LANDLORD has no such right; if it is unhappy with the terms of the new lease, the only remedy is to APPEAL
242
what happens where the landlord successfully opposes the grant of the new lease on one or more of the no fault grounds? (e.g. (e) (f) and (g)) can you contract out of the above consequences?
- not be granted a new lease - but will be awarded compensation - amount of compensation will be equivalent to the RATEABLE VALUE OF THE HOLDING - if the tenant and their predecessors in the same business have been in occupation for AT LEAST 14 years, when it will be TWICE THE RATEABLE VALUE - any AGREEMENT restricting or EXCLUDING the payment of compensation is VOID if the tenant or their predecessors in the same business have been in OCCUPATION FOR 5 YRS OR MORE
243
A protected tenancy cannot be terminated other than by one of the seven ways laid down by the 1954 Act. how does a s.27 notice work?
- a protected tenant who wants to terminate the lease ON the contractual expiry date may do so by : i) CEASING TO OCCUPY for business purposes by the end of the lease or ii) serving a s 27 notice giving the landlord 3 MONTHS PRIOR WRITTEN NOTICE - a protected tenant who wants to terminate the lease AFTER the contractual expiry date can do so by: i) serving a s 27 notice giving the landlord 3 MONTHS NOTICE or ii) AGREEING A VOLUNTARY SURRENDER of the lease with the landlord
244
A landlord granted a lease of a retail property nine years ago for a term of 10 years. The lease reserved a rent of £100,000 per year, payable monthly in advance. Yesterday, the tenant completed the purchase of the landlord’s freehold interest in the property. Has the lease come to an end? a) No, because the lease will automatically continue unless notice is served under section 25 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954. b) Yes, because the lease has merged with the landlord’s reversionary interest in the property.
the correct answer is b a is wrong because continuation under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 will only apply once the contractual term of the lease has expired. b is correct because the lease has merged with the landlord’s reversionary interest in the property.
245
In an open market rent review clause there will be assumptions and disregards. These assumptions and disregards are designed to ensure that rent reviews are fair, based on the market conditions, and not influenced by factors specific to the tenant or their occupation of the property. what are some common disregards? why are they disregards?
i) 'any effect on rent of the fact that the tenant has been in OCCUPATION of the property' - prevent the tenant from being unfairly penalized or benefiting from their ongoing presence (e.g., avoiding relocation costs). ii) 'any GOODWILL attached to the property by reason of any business carried out there by the tenant' e.g. regular flow of customers or good reputation iii) 'any effect on the rent attributable to any PHYSICAL IMPROVEMENT to the property carried out by the tenant with all necessary consents and not pursuant to an obligation to the landlord' - ensures that the rent isn't artificially inflated or reduced based on the tenant’s contributions to the property’s value.
246
A draft lease contains the following covenant to pay rent: “The tenant shall pay the Annual Rent by equal quarterly payments in advance on the Rent Days. The first payment will be for the period starting on (and to be paid on) the date of this lease and ending on the last day of that quarter.” The interpretation section includes: “Rent Days: 25 March, 24 June, 29 September, 25 December.” Today’s date is 25 February. The lease will commence 1 June this year. when is the first full quarterly rent payment due? A) The first full quarterly rent payment is due on 1 June this year as the rent is payable in advance and this is the lease commencement date. B) The first full quarterly rent payment is due on 24 June this year as rent is payable in advance and this is the first Rent Day after the lease commencement date.
B is the correct answer - the tenant will make an interim (apportioned) payment on the lease commencement date to take it through to the first Rent Day after the lease commences. Then a full quarterly rent payment will become due on the first Rent Day after the lease commences.
247
A client is the tenant of commercial leasehold premises. The lease was granted three years’ ago and the tenant has agreed to assign the lease. The lease contains a fully qualified covenant against assignment. Contracts for the assignment of the lease (incorporating the Standard Commercial Property Conditions – Third Edition 2018 Revision (‘SCPC’)) were exchanged today. At the time of the exchange the landlord’s consent to the assignment had not been obtained. Which of the following best explains the position on landlord’s consent? A) the completion must be postponed to allow the landlord's consent to be obtained B) the assignment can proceed to completion without landlord’s consent providing the landlord’s consent is obtained within five working days of the actual completion date
option B is the correct answer. The landlord’s consent DOES NOT HAVE TO BE OBTAINED PRIOR to the EXCHANGE OF CONTRACTS (although it would be preferable commercially if it had been). The landlord’s consent must be obtained in order for the assignment to proceed to completion and the landlord can withhold consent if it is reasonable to do so. The SCPC provide for COMPLETION TO BE POSTPONED until five working days after the seller notifies the buyer of the landlord’s consent or if a court declares the consent has been unreasonably withheld.
248
A company has a periodic tenancy of some business premises. The tenancy is not protected by any security of tenure regime as the company is not in occupation of the premises. Rent is expressed to be payable in advance on the historic quarter days, being 25 March, 24 June, 29 September and 25 December. It is now 10 January. The landlord wishes to bring the lease to an end as soon as possible by serving notice on the company. The company is not in breach of any leasehold covenants. If the landlord were to serve notice today, which of the following best describes the earliest date on which the lease will come to an end? a) Immediately: the notice will allow the landlord to forfeit the lease and peacefully re-enter the premises. b) Immediately: the notice will allow the landlord to disclaim the lease. c) 7 February: the landlord must give the company four weeks’ notice. d) 24 March: the lease will come to an end the day before the next rent payment is due. e) 23 June: the lease will come to an end when the next clear period expires.
Option E is correct. A periodic tenancy can be brought to an end by either party serving notice to quit. The general rule is that one full period’s notice is required. In this case, each period lasts a quarter (ie 3 months). If notice to quit is served on 10 January, the earliest date on which the lease will come to an end is 23 June, being the end of the next clear period (25 March to 23 June). Option A is wrong. We are told that the company is not in breach of any leasehold covenants. There is therefore no basis for the landlord to forfeit the lease and immediately re-enter the premises. Option B is wrong. Disclaimer arises upon the liquidation of a tenant, the liquidator having the power to disclaim contracts which give rise to a liability to pay money or perform any onerous act. There is no ground on the facts for the landlord to disclaim the lease. Option C is wrong. The Protection from Eviction Act 1977 provides that landlords must give tenants at least 4 weeks’ notice before seeking possession of premises. However, the Act relates to premises let as dwelling houses where the tenant is in occupation, neither of which is the case here. In any event, the landlord in this case must give the tenant more than 4 weeks’ notice – the periods of the lease run on a quarterly basis, requiring the landlord to give the company at least 3 months’ notice. Option D is wrong. The landlord must give the company at least one full period’s notice. We are already in the period that is due to expire on 24 March. The lease cannot therefore be brought to an end on that date as that will not give the company a full period’s notice.
249
The open market rent review clause states that in determining the open market rent the valuer will: assume that the Tenant has complied with its repairing obligations. Would this be acceptable to a tenant?
Yes, it would be reasonable for the rent review clause to assume that the tenant has fully complied with its repair obligations, otherwise the tenant could benefit from a reduced rent as a result of its own failure to repair the property.
250
what are the time limits in which LPAs must bring enforcement action if they think there has been a breach in planning control?
- UK = within 10 years of breach - 4 years if... a) breaches involving operational development (such as building works) OR b) changing the use of a building to use as a single dwelling house that took place before 25 April 2024 WALES: - breaches involving operational development (such as building works) or changing the use of a building to use as a single dwelling house = 4 years - all other breaches = 10 years
251
how is the covenant to sell the property free from incumbrances different for full title than it is limited title?
FULL TITLE - covenanting that land is disposed free from incumbrances other than those the seller does not know about and could not reasonably know about - this is a wider covenant than provided w. limited title LIMITED TITLE - seller has not incumbered the property and is not aware that anyone else has done so since the last disposition for value - (so a seller who purchased the land for value will only be covenanting that incumbrances have not been created since they acquired the property)
252
A seller can sell a property with three different kinds of title guarantee. What are they?
full title = entire legal and equitable title to the property limited title = seller has limited knowledge of the property, eg where the seller is an executor or trustee no title guarantee = eg where the seller is a person appointed following the insolvency of the owner
253
what do the standard conditions provide for regarding whether title is full, limited or no title guarantee?
full title - so if selling with limited or no title > need to amend the standard conditions
254
Usually, liability for damage to the property lies with the buyer following exchange of contract. However, it is likely the seller will not cancel their policy in case the buyer fails to complete or because it is a term of their mortgage contract that the policy is maintained. What impact might this have on insurance pay-outs? How do the standard conditions provide for this?
Where there are two policies in place on the same property, there is a danger that when a claim is made, the buyer’s insurer will reduce the proceeds because another policy exists. Standard conditions therefore provide that if this happens and the buyer is unable to recover the full amount of the proceeds, the purchase price is reduced accordingly.
255
if an assignor is in breach of a repairing covenant in the lease when they assign the lease to the assignee, the assignee will become liable for remedying the breaches. why is this? what should be amended to reflect this?
- where the assignor sells with full or limited title, the covenants for title include a promise that the assignor has complied with the tenant's covenants in the lease (including repair) - however, the principle of caveat emptor makes it the assignee's responsibility to check the physical state of the premises - solution = modify the covenants to exclude references to repair - this is covered by both standard conditions - BUT there must also be an express modification pf the implied covenants for title IN THE TRANSFER DEED ITSELF - amend to something like "the covenants set out in s.4 LP(MP)A will not extend to any breach of the tenant's covenants relating to the physical state of the property"
256
USE CLASS ORDERS
257
what is the difference between the classes of title and the title guarantees?
classes of title: - LRs confidence in establishing ownership at registration - each class indicates the degree of certainty or completeness regarding the ownership of the land - absolute, qualified + possessory title guarantees: - assurance provided by the seller regarding their right to sell and the property's title - full, limited, no
258
A solicitor is acting for a retailer buying shop premises at 1 Clyde Way, Solihull. The seller, Land Investments Limited, bought the premises in 1970 and title is unregistered. The solicitor has received the Epitome of title which contains a pre-root conveyance referred to in the root of title document. The pre-root conveyance is dated 1 April 1930 and between (1) Edith Jones and (2) Colin Bligh. It contains the following covenant:‘The Purchaser with the intent and so as to bind the property hereby conveyed and to benefit and protect the retained land of the Vendor (known as 3 Clyde Way, Solihull) hereby covenants with the Vendor not to use the property other than as offices’. The solicitor’s assistant has carried out a land charges search against Edith Jones for the period 1925 to 1930 and Land Investments Limited for the period 1970 to the current year. This has not revealed any entries that relate to 1Clyde Way. Should the solicitor be concerned about the covenant? a) No, because the covenant has not been registered as a land charge against the seller b) Yes, because the personal assistant should have conducted a land charges search against Colin Bligh for the period 1930 to 1970
Option B is the correct answer. A post 1925 restrictive covenant will bind in unregistered land if it is registered against the relevant estate owner as a land charge (in this case Colin Bligh). The solicitor should be concerned as no land charges search has been carried out against Coin Bligh. If the restrictive covenant is registered against Colin Bligh’s name it will bind. Option A is incorrect because the covenant would be registered as a land charge against the party who originally gave the covenant- Colin Bligh.
259
A solicitor advising a prospective tenant on the grant of a commercial lease is reviewing the draft lease provision for rent review. The rent review clause contains the following disregards and assumption: Disregards: Any effect of the tenant being in occupation, any goodwill because of the tenant’s occupation and any increase in rent attributable to the tenant’s improvements. Assumption: The tenant has complied with their covenants under the lease. What best describes the effect of these assumptions and disregards on the parties? a) The disregards and the assumption are equally favourable to both the landlord and the tenant. b) The disregards all favour the tenant and the assumption favours the landlord.
Option B is correct. The disregards all favour the tenant. This is because: If the effect of the tenant being in occupation was not disregarded it would increase the rent as a tenant would pay a higher rent to stay where they are, rather than have to move. If the effect of any goodwill was not disregarded this would increase the rent as a tenant would pay an increased rent to benefit from the goodwill attached to the premises. If the tenant’s improvements were not disregarded, the tenant would be paying an increased rent as a result of improvements they had paid for and would effectively be penalised financially for improving the property. The assumption that the tenant’s covenants have been complied with favours the landlord because if the tenant’s covenants have not been complied with and for example the property was in a state of disrepair, this would decrease the rent and the tenant would benefit from its non-compliance.
260
A landlord owns a property which is let to a business tenant on a 10 year fixed term lease. The contractual term expires in just over six months’ time and the landlord wishes to serve a s 25 notice on the tenant opposing the grant of a new tenancy today. The landlord acquired the property four and a half years ago and wishes to move into the property itself when the tenant leaves. Last year the tenant failed to pay the June instalment of the rent but has otherwise been a good tenant. Which of the following statements is the best advice to the landlord as to which ground(s) to specify in its s 25 notice? a) The landlord cannot rely on ground (g) because it has only owned the property for four and half years. b) The landlord is unlikely to be able to rely on ground (b) but could rely on ground (g).
Option B is correct. On the facts, the two grounds that are potentially available to the landlord are (b) and (g). Ground (b) is discretionary and ground (g) is mandatory. Ground (b) is available where there has been a persistent failure by the tenant to pay rent. The tenant has only missed one rent payment and so it is unlikely that the landlord could rely upon it. Options B, D and E are, therefore, not the best advice. Option B is also misconceived as it would not be better to rely on a discretionary ground where a mandatory ground is available. Option D is correct that ground (b) is a non-compensatory ground and this might have been a reason for choosing it had it been available. Ground (g) is available where, at the termination of the lease, the landlord intends to occupy the premises as its business or residence. This is not available if the landlord acquired its interest in the property within five years of the ending of the current tenancy. This will be the termination date specified in the s 25 notice. Although the landlord has not yet owned its interest in the property for five years on the date of service of the s 25 notice, it will have done so by the termination date specified in the s 25 notice and so will not be barred from relying on ground (g). Option A is therefore wrong.
261
A solicitor is acting for a buyer who is purchasing a property with registered title. The property consists of a converted barn and courtyard garden. The seller originally purchased the property from the owner and occupier of the adjacent farmhouse. The title to the property includes a right of access to the barn from the highway over the driveway that also serves the farmhouse. This right is however subject to an obligation to contribute towards the maintenance of the driveway. The driveway falls within the title to the farmhouse. What advice should be given to the buyer about their right to use the driveway? a) The buyer has an express right to use the driveway but in order to do so must contribute towards the cost of maintaining the driveway. b) The buyer will be required to obtain consent from the owner of the farmhouse in order to gain access to the barn over the driveway. c) The buyer has an express right to use the driveway but will not be required to contribute towards the maintenance as that is a positive covenant which will not bind the buyer.
Option A is correct. The buyer will have an express right to use the driveway but will be required to contribute towards the maintenance of the driveway if it wants to exercise the right in accordance with the rule in Halsall v Brizell. The rule in Halsall v Brizell circumvents the general position that a positive covenant is not binding on successors in title. The right of way has been registered against the title therefore the buyer will automatically benefit from the right upon purchase of the property. The right of way has been registered therefore it is an express right.
262
A solicitor is asked to advise a client regarding the purchase of a property near a medieval church. Title to the property is registered. There is no notice of any chancel repair liability on the registers of title for the property. The last transfer for value was on 20 July 2002. Which of the following best describes the client's position? A) The client will not be bound by chancel repair liability B) The client may be bound by a chancel repair liability, so it is advisable that the solicitor still undertakes a chancel repair screening search
Option B is correct as there is a risk that there could be a chancel liability in these circumstances as the last disposition was prior to 13 October 2013 (when chancel repair liabilities lost their overriding status). The client could still be bound if an application to protect chancel repair liabilities was made after the client has completed their title investigation but prior to registration of his transfer, so the solicitor might still undertake a chancel repair screening search to check for liability.
263
is it necessary to search against lenders that appear in the epitome of title or just estate owners?
just estate owners - unless there is some indication the lender had possession of the property at some point
264
A landlord granted a lease of office premises in England to a tenant for a term of 15 years today. The consideration for the lease is the payment of a commercial, open-market rent with a premium of £150,000. The landlord opted to tax the property for VAT purposes before the lease was granted. Will the tenant have to pay tax? If so, on what?
The tenant will have to pay SDLT on the VAT-inclusive amounts of the rent and the premium. On the grant of a lease, SDLT is potentially payable both on any premium charged by the landlord and the rent reserved by the lease. Where VAT is chargeable (because the landlord has opted to tax the property before the grant of the lease), SDLT is charged on the VAT-inclusive amounts. SDLT will be charged on the rent (which is open market so more than nominal) and the premium as the VAT-inclusive amount of the premium is £180,000 (£150,000 + £30,000 VAT). The applicable rate for consideration exceeding £150,000 is 2%.
265
new leases (granted after 1 Jan 1996) should include an express indemnity covenant where the assignor is to remain liable for the assignee's conduct via an AGA. true or false?
true - and the standard conditions entitle the assignor to insert an indemnity in such circumstances
266
what is the difference between CON29 + CON29O?
CON29 - standard enquiries - planning permissions - Article 4 directions - whether the land has been designated as contaminated - liability for road repair CON29O - optional enquiries - wide range of searches - environmental + pollution notices - rights over common land
267
what is the main limitation with the local land charges search? for example, if the buyer wants a view over adjoining fields surrounding the property?
- CON29 + CON29O only search in respect of the property - not the adjoining land - so would need to check for any proposed developments on the adjoining land
268
what are LCC1 and CON29 + O?
- they are enquiries with local authorities - just give different results
269
what is the quickest method of exchange of contract?
telephone
270
what is the main advantage and disadvantage of exchanging contracts in person?
- certainty > sols physically receive the contract - sols don't usually have the time > could send agent > additional cost
271
what is the difference between a title plan and copy?
- title plan = depicts the boundaries of the property - title copy = reproduces the register of title
272
how does deduction of title differ when granting a lease and assigning a lease?
GRANTING A LEASE: - SC provide for deduction of freehold title if > 7 years - underleases > headlease is unregistered > entitled to call for headlease + subsequent assignments within last 15 years ASSIGNMENT: - entitled to call for lease + any assignments within last 15 years - not entitled to call for deduction of freehold title
273
how does a licence to underlet deal with contractual liability of an underlease?
- undertenant enters into direct covenant with head landlord to perform the covenants in both the lease + underlease (only to extent they relate to underlet property) - excludes headlease covenants to pay rent (otherwise there would be double rent) - this direct covenant creates contractual relationship between head landlord + sub tenant > can sue for any breaches (other than for non-payment of rent > rent will be paid by sub tenant to head-tenant)
274
what are the key provisions in a licence to underlet?
1. landlord's consent 2. direct covenant from sub-tenant to head landlord 3. head-tenant pays head landlord's costs for licence
275
what are the names of the two certificates of title?
- LSU + CLL - residential > Law Society and UK Finance - com prop > City of London Law Society
276
list the common assumptions that could be drafted into an open market rent review clause....
1. 'by willing landlord to a willing tenant' - without them the hypothetical letting would not take place at all 2. 'with vacant possession' - the hypothetical tenant wouldn't make an offer unless the property was empty 3. 'on the terms of this lease other than as to the amount of annual rent, but including the provisions for review of annual rent' - provisions of hypothetical lease = same as real lease - except rent (which is likely to change) - would not be fair for the hypothetical lease to have more generous terms as this would artificially increase the rent 4.'for a term of X years' - the lease should specify the term of the hypothetical lease - difficult > may be effected by market conditions e.g if there is a recession > tenants want greater flexibility + thus shorter terms > so a 15 year hypothetical lease would depress the rent term - potential solution: term equal to the unexpired residue of the actual term 5. 'on the assumption that the tenant has fully complied with their obligations in this lease' - tenant should not profit from its failure to repair the property 6. 'on the assumption that if the property has been destroyed or damaged, it has been fully restored' - if property damaged a week before rent review > wouldnt be fair to review rent on the state of the property when the LL wouldnt have had chance to reinstate
277
explain a tenant's liability for the covenants in a lease, if the lease was granted: - before 1 Jan 1996 - on or after 1 Jan 1996
OLD LEASE: - liability lasts for the duration of the lease - original tenant bound by privity of contract - current tenant bound by privity of estate - may even sue intervening tenants > common for LL to require direct covenant on each assignment NEW LEASE: - liability only lasts whilst lease is vested in T (so released from liability on assignment) - to compensate for this the LL is able to stipulate requirement of consent + AGA: i) tenant bound whilst there are an assignee ii) will be bound following assignment if AGA iii) AGA only binds them whist the new assignee remains tenant
278
list the potential remedies available to a LL for breach of the covenant to pay rent...
1. action in debt 2. CRAR 3. pursing guarantors 4. pursuing former tenants 5. deducting from the rent deposit 6. forfeiture
279
list the potential remedies available to a LL for breach of the repair covenant....
1. action for damages (against current + former tenants + their guarantors) 2. specific performance 3. self-help clause 4. forfeiture
280
list the potential remedies available to a LL for breach of other covenants e.g. breach of user covenant....
1. action in DAMAGES (against current + former tenants + their respective guarantors) 2. INJUNCTION - equitable + discretionary - for breach of user covenant - to prevent assignment 3. SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE - equitable + discretionary - positive obligation - performance sufficiently precedes - supervision over a period of time not required - damages not adequate remedy 4. FORFEITURE 5. DEDUCTION FROM RDD - provided RDD provides for deductions in such circumstances
281
which is the only remedy available to a LL for breach of covenant which allows them to regain possession of the property?
forfeiture
282
how does action in debt act as a remedy for a LL for a tenant's breach of the covenant to pay rent?
- non payment of rent = debt - can be recovered through HC or CC - Limitation Act > 6 years
283
how does CRAR act as a remedy for a LL for a tenant's breach of the covenant to pay rent?
- commercial rent arrears recovery - 7 days rent must be outstanding - only for rent for possession of property (not insurance rent) - enforcement agency enters property (on behalf of LL) + seizes goods - must give 7 days notice of intention to enter - items up to £1350 necessary for tenant's business cannot be removed - can take property tenant has an interest in e.g. co-owned or mortgage - cant take leased or hire purchase property - if tenant doesnt pay the arrears > sell - sold at public auction - tenant given 7 clears days' notice of sale
284
how does pursuing former guarantors act as a remedy for a LL for a tenant's breach of the covenant to pay rent?
- LL will have required guarantor if reservations about Ts financial stability - e.g. newly formed PLC or unknown new co. - guarantee must be in writing - the guarantee will: 1) oblige the guarantor to pay the rent + any other sums due 2) to remedy or indemnify the LL against any loss suffered as a result of the breach
285
how would a LL pursue a guarantor of a former tenant for non-payment of rent?
OLD LEASE: - liability of a guarantor likely to extend throughout assignments NEW LEASE: - liability of guarantor released on assignment - cant ask outgoing tenant's guarantor to guarantee new tenant - any attempt to do so = likely to be void - but LL may require the guarantor of the outgoing tenant to guarantee the outgoing tenant's obligation under the AGA - this indirectly guarantees the incoming tenant until further assignment both need to serve s.17 notice
286
how would a LL pursue a former tenant for the current tenant's breach of the rent covenant?
OLD LEASE: - if the former tenant is the original tenant > privity of contract - likely that each subsequent tenant will have given direct covenant to the landlord to observe the covenants in the lease NEW LEASE: - previous tenant under the AGA both need to serve s.17 notice
287
where a LL intends to pursue...: a) former tenant b) guarantor of former tenant .... for the current tenant's non-payment of rent, what must it do? - is this the same for old and new leases?
- comply with s.17 LT(C)A 1995 - serve default notice ('s.17 notice') - stating they intend to recover a 'fixed charge' - must be served within 6 months of the current tenant's breach - LL does not have to start proceedings > the notice is simply giving notice of the claim - applies to old + new leases
288
how does a former tenant or former tenant's guarantor obtain control over a property they have been served a s.17 notice on?
- if they pay the sum claimed under the default notice - they can then call for an 'overriding lease' - makes the former tenant/former tenant's guarantor the immediate landlord of the defaulting tenant
289
how does a rent deposit operate as a remedy for the LL for a tenant's breach of the covenant to pay rent?
- LL can require rent deposit as security payment - generally 6-12 months rent - the circumstances which entitle the LL to withdraw money from it or repay some of it = set out in rent deposit deed (RDD) - provided no breach of RDD by LL > LL can immediately withdrawn upon breach from T - the RDD will often require the T to then top up the RD - the RD balance returned to the T at end of term or on assignment
290
which is the only remedy available to a LL following breach of covenant that will bring a lease to an end?
forfeiture
291
how can forfeiture be used as a remedy for a LL for a tenant's breach of the covenant to pay rent?
- must be a forfeiture clause in the lease - may be called something else 'provisos' + 're-entry' - common law requires a formal demand for payment to be made - but a lease can dispense with this requirement - often the clause will say how long the rent must have been outstanding for - LL has two options for obtaining possession: 1) peaceable re-entry, or if this is not possible... 2) court order - T can apply to court for relief from forfeiture - court has discretion to allow the lease to continue (subject to condition that T pays all arrears + costs) - LL may waive right to forfeit by demonstrating intention to continue L&T relationship - so LL should not demand or accept rent after breach has arisen
292
how can specific performance be used as a remedy for a LL where the T has breached the repair covenant?
- equitable remedy - forces the tenant to comply with the positive covenant - only granted where other remedies not appropriate
293
how will damages be used as a remedy for a LL where the T has breached the repair covenant?
- breach of contract - what losses were in the contemplation of the parties? - s.18 LTA 1927 > can only claim for the amount the LLs reversion has diminished in value (this may be less than the cost of the repairs) - leases granted for 7 or more years w. more than 3 left to run > special procedure: i) notice must be served on T ii) T has right to serve counter notice within 28 days iii) if T does so, LL cannot continue with the claim without leave of the court
294
how will a self-help/Jervis v Harris clause act as a remedy for a LL where the T has breached the repair covenant?
- must have clause in the lease - allows to recover for cost of repairs as a debt + not as damages (avoid s.18 limitations) - LL allowed to enter property to check compliance with repair covenant - if breached > LL serves notice specifying works needed to remedy - if T fails to start work or is not proceeding diligently > LL enter + carry out works themselves
295
what is the procedure for forfeiture for breach of a repair covenant?
- follow stat procedure > s.146 LPA 1925 1. service 146 notice - specifies breach - requires breach to be rectified within r. time - require T to pay compensation for breach 2. if no compliance > LL enter via: - peaceable re-entry - court order - T can apply for relief from court 3. where lease is for 7yrs or more + at least 3 years left: - s.146 notice must include notification of T's right to serve counter-notice within 28 days - if T serves counter-notice > can only proceed with forfeiture with leave of court
296
how is the procedure for forfeiture different where there has been a breach of: 1) covenant to pay rent 2) covenant to repair 3) other covenants e.g user
- similarities include: a) need forfeiture clause in lease b) peaceable re-entry or court order c) T can apply for relief > can only continue with leave of the court - differences re notice requirements: 1) RENT - default notice > can dispense with this requirement in the lease 2) REPAIR - s.146 notice - where 7yr lease + at least 3 left to run > must include Ts ability to file counter notice within 28 days 3) OTHER COVENANTS - s.146 notice - no need to include right to serve counter notice
297
what is another method a LL could use to address breaches of covenant by T? HINT: it is not a remedy in a technical sense, but more of a practical method
- surrender - deed could deal with arrears - might be attractive to the T as a way of terminating its obligations - potentially quicker + cheaper than forfeiture - dependent on both parties being willing
298
what are the key lease covenants for the LL + T?
LL: 1. quiet enjoyment 2. insurance T: 1. rent 2. contribution to insurance 3. repair 4. alterations 5. alienatio
299
in the absence of such provisions, two LL covenants are implied into a lease... - what are they? - what do they provide?
QUIET ENJOYMENT - not substantially interfered with by acts of LL - res T further protected by: Protection from Eviction Act - prevents LL unlawfully depriving T of their occupation - any acts done with the intent to force the T to give up their occupation = offence FITNESS OF THE PROPERTY - res. property > s.11 LTA obliges LL to keep in repair: a) structure + exterior b) installations for supply of water, gas, electricity, sanitation + heating - only obliged if there is disrepair + they have been notified of this
300
a current assignee for an old lease is liable for breaches of all real covenants. what does 'real' covenants mean? how does this differ for a new lease?
- includes positive + restrictive covenants - e.g. to pay rent or to use the property in a certain way (i) a ‘touching and concerning’ covenant must benefit only the dominant owner for the time being, so that, if separated from their land, it ceases to be advantageous to them [the land benefits not the owner] (ii) the covenant must affect the nature, quality, mode of user or value of the land of the dominant owner; and (iii) the covenant must not be expressed to be personal (ie must not have been given only to one specific dominant owner). - new lease > all covenants pass regardless of whether they are 'real' - only ones that dont > those expressed to be personal
301
how can an original tenant (old lease) or former tenant (new lease) that has entered into an AGA, recover sums from the assignee where they have breached the lease?
1. principle in Moule v Garrett - where one person discharges the liability of another, that person may seek to recover the amount they have paid from the person whose liability they have discharged 2. on the basis of an express indemnity covenant given by the assignee - contained in the deed of assignment - note for old leases an indemnity covenant is implied on every assignment
302
what obligations do LLs have when the reversionary interest (ie the right to regain possession of the property when lease ends) is sold?
- acquires burden of LL covenants + benefits of T covenants (provided the covenants were not expressed to be personal) - outgoing LL is not automatically released on sale - have to follow stat criteria - get around this by stating in lease that LL only responsible whilst they hold the reversion - otherwise T can pursue current LL and previous
303
explain the position regarding relief from forfeiture for a tenant and a sub-tenant...
- court may grant relief on terms it sees fit - if asking for relief > must come with clean hands SUB-TENANT - if head lease is forfeited > sub-lease ceases to exist - sub T can apply for relief from forfeiture of head lease (even where T cannot obtain relief) - court would vest the head lease in the sub-lessee on such terms as the court sees fit (ie sub-lessee becomes the only tenant)
304
which remedies does a tenant have if a LL breaches its covenants in a lease?
1. SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE - equitable + discretionary 2. DAMAGES - ordinary contractual principles apply 3. SELF HELP / JERVIS v HARRIS - doesn't entitle T to withhold rent - may notify LL repair needs doing + if LL fails to do so > T can complete - if T then completes > can withhold rent until cost of repair has been repaid (common law set off) - if T does withhold rent + LL sues > equity may allow tenant to have their sum set off against the liability - only where the two claims are sufficiently connected that it would be manifestly unjust not to allow set off NOTE: most well drafted leases will exclude set off
305
how does disclaimer terminate a lease?
- bankruptcy (B) or liquidation (L) of a tenant - trustee in B or L can disclaim contracts which give rise to a liability to pay money or perform an onerous act - releases tenant from liability - does not end sub-tenancy - a sub-tenant may seek an order to vest the disclaimed property in themselves
306
when can a LL require an AGA?
1. if lease contains alienation covenant that requires LLs consent 2. it is reasonable to do so 3. comm. lease > if it is a requirement of the LLs consent
307
what is a RDD?
- rent deposit deed - legal document outlining the terms of a rent deposit - T provides a sum of money to the LL as security for the performance of their lease obligations - gives LL some financial security