Babies are born selfish and have to learn how to be good through inputs and positive influence
Traditional view of child moral development
Helping others in a way where the helper receives no immediate benefit, especially when the person being helped is a stranger
Altruistic helping
Describe a study that shows that using a clothespin, children were found to help people
Adult was unable to reach a for a clothespin, 70% of children picked it up. Were able to rule out alternative explanations such as children being concerned with cleanliness/playing catch by making a condition where children did not need any help, and kid then does not help the adult
Describe the cabinet altruism study.
Have someone with a stack of magazines but unable to get them into a cabinet= 40% of children helped open the cabinet. Ruled out children opening the cabinet out of the sound of the cabinet being bumped into by having someone bump in the cabinet and not try to open it, suggests that babies are willing to help
When does reactive helping first emerge?
18 months
Strong cues that help is needed leading to people helping (such as reaching)
Reactive helping
Helping where there are very few cues that help is needed (such as someone dropping their wallet and not noticing)
Proactive helping
Provide an example of children’s proactive helping through a milk can
Toddler is playing with a toy in the middle of the room, experimenter is in front of table and putting milk cans in the box and one of the milk cans roll off the table. See if children pick up the milk cans, most did
When did proactive helping emerge?
24 months
Helping where people don’t do the task that is asked of them, rather doing a task that is more helpful for the help-seeker
Paternalistic helping
Provide an example of paternalistic helping
Children were introduced to pairs of objects, one was functional (such as working cell phone, cup, hammer, marker, etc), and dysfunctional. (Cup has a hole, hammer is squishy, etc). Adult asks for either the dysfunctional object or the functional one. Results were that for phone and cup children would give the functional one if they were asked for dysfunctional ones
Provide a counter study to the idea that children help for reputation
Toddlers help anonymously, and would help even if there is a curtain blocking the experimenters’s view of the toddler
When does paternalistic helping begin to emerge?
3 year olds
Provide a study that counters the assumption that children help because they may be rewarded for helping
Group A is conditioned to get no reward for helping while Group B is conditioned to help reward for helping by being given a toy. Same person needs help with no reward, and group a is more willing to help- conditioned children expect a reward for helping
What is a potential objection for children being born good?
Research has focused on 18 months or older, could actually be unlearning selfish tendencies over time, but its hard to get into the mind of newborns
How can nature and nurture for children’s altruism be observed?
By observing animals- and evolutionary relatives show altruism
If human socialization is necessary, we _____ find altruistic tendencies in ape
In human socialization is necessary wouldn’t find these tendencies in other apes
Do chimpanzees and bonobos also help others altruistically? What does this suggest about children?
Chimpanzees and bonobos also help others altruistically, so children helping may be a natural tendency without human socialization
Early helping may serve an important function in development because of the way it affects ____. When was this the case? Provide examples
Early helping may serve an important function in development because of the way if affects adults, particularly in foraging societies and family chores
By at least 3.5 years old, children prefer to share resources with ____ rather than strangers
By at least 3.5. Years old, children prefer to share with close relationships rather than strangers
Provide an example to children using reciprocity to choose who to help
Each individual is putting golf balls down the ramp, until they run out , but partners still has balls left. Partner shares or does not share, and then children swaps scenario (they have balls or the others one don’t). 2.5 year olds share regardless of condition and 3.5 share depending on partners behavior
What is the new view of children’s altruism?
Babies are born good (naive cooperators) and become mature cooperators/learn when it is more appropriate to help q
Provide an example where children were tested on inequality
Given a scenario where child has to split five erasers between two people. (Also given an equality division condition). Nearly all 6-8 year olds did the equality condition properly but threw away the extra resource in the inequality condition. Findings were found in US and Africa and children didn’t care about experimenter prioritizing another person or if no one would find out about inequality
How was it found that children were willing to have equality even if they did not benefit?
When child was in experiment, chose to throw an unequal resource away even if they could have gotten the extra resource